3 ms·
It's my business because, should they have it their way, I wouldn't be alive. Asking people to be tolerant of ideologies that pose an existential threat is con
by woodruffw 8y ago
It's my business because, should they have it their way, I wouldn't be alive.
Asking people to be tolerant of ideologies that pose an existential threat is contradictory at best.
- smhost 8y agoThe fact that this has to be explained at all shows just how much hacker news is overrun with fascist moral relativism. There's even a guy equating nazis with jews. What the fuck happened to you people?
- mc32 8y agoThis is a difficult question. Communism has led to countless unjust senseless deaths. Many people alive would be dead in a traditionally communist regime. Should we make communism objectionable as a political ideology? (note: I am not saying naziism should not be objectionable, just that we have an equally deadly ideology that has some acceptance) These things are fraught with complication.
- woodruffw 8y agoCommunism, expressed as the kind that killed all those people, is objectionable. I object to it, and it seems like a broad segment of the population agrees. However, that just isn't the same as what I'm describing. There is nothing analytical about communism that poses an existential threat to me. Neo-Nazism, on other other hand, is a priori incompatible with my existence.
- mc32 8y agoI do see this difference. However, in practice communism and faschism are pretty much two sides of the same coin. One has specific victims (though like communism, none stated, but there is always the out-group, I mean, you see Black African nazi sympathizers in Africa) communism also has an out-group: whether it be the owner-class or people who get in the way of their ideology.
- woodruffw 8y agoSure, there's plenty of violence in the world. I am opposed to most forms of it. But no, there is no equivocation here. One of these things (Neo-Nazism) is fundamentally incompatible, even just on the linguistic level, with my existence. The other (Communism) is undesirable and even reprehensible, but doesn't threaten the mode of discourse itself. Put another way: proposing tolerance towards analytically intolerant ideas amounts to an "disagreement" between a linguistic claim and a claim about the language itself. I wrote about the danger of viewing these as normal "disagreements" about a week ago[1]. [1]: https://blog.yossarian.net/2018/08/20/Disagreement-Language-Metalanguage https://blog.yossarian.net/2018/08/20/Disagreement-Language-...
- jobserunder 8y agoAll Communism leads to that. Every single instance has led to suppressing, sacrificing individuals for the Collective. Forcing someone at gunpoint to be "kind" to their neighbor because it is their "duty" is never a good starting point. The whole premise is messed up. Taking peoples houses, possessions and giving it to others is a sure fire why to demotivate people and slam the brakes on the economy.
- austhrow743 8y agoPeople have cooperated with existential threats for economic gain for a very long time. Trade today, kill each other tomorrow. It's not contradictory at all.
- woodruffw 8y agoThis assumes that the software engineering market is so strapped for hires that it needs neo-Nazis. I don't buy that. But more to the point: the contradiction isn't economic, it's linguistic. See the comment thread below.
- r00fus 8y agoAnd what kinds of societies and organizations so these dire situations blossom in? Crime organizations, autocratic regimes and slavery countries. Sorry I don't want to work for or live in that kind of setting. I wouldn't want anyone to be forced to do so.