3 ms·
It's mostly due to the increasing evidence of: * Clear biases in distribution of bail vs. non-bail gated release * The substantially unbalanced cost of bail f
by olliej 8y ago
It's mostly due to the increasing evidence of:
* Clear biases in distribution of bail vs. non-bail gated release
* The substantially unbalanced cost of bail for poor vs. middle-class and up. Basically: if your bail costs $1000 and you make $50k/year you can probably arrange cash to cover it. If you make 20k/year you probably cannot, so your option is to lose $100 - bail bond is not returned to you - or you literally go to jail without a trial.
- Analemma_ 8y agoBut the improved ability to track people probably helps sell it politically to the "tough on crime" crowd.
- jaxn 8y agoFaster due process has a much bigger impact than tracking people down (which is both expensive and dangerous). There will also likely be an increase in "no bond" holds until the court date. This is a step in the right direction, but the entire incarceration machine needs an overhaul/downsize.
- olliej 8y agomy inclination is that all non-violent offenses should be on recognizance (or however that's worded) unless there's historic evidence that you will miss your court dates. If you have previously skipped court dates then we shouldn't necessarily assume that you would make future court dates, so why do we believe bail would mean anything?
- woolvalley 8y agoWould you call physical theft a violent or non-violent crime? How about if that theft involved property damage?
- olliej 8y agoHonestly: I don't know. Seriously, I'm not saying these problems are easy, I'm saying that the current policies of anything and everything can lead to jail time results in long term negative effects that exacerbate existing biases. The current bail system feeds on this - if all crimes carry the potential for jail time, then all defendants can be threatened with jail time in exchange for a plea bargain that has a false confession. Let's say we go for something like "no direct victims" e.g. possession, drunk and disorderly, etc have no jail penalty, theft or violent crime does? But then how to you class smashing a window during a protest: Is that deserving of jail time? If not, then why is there the threat of incarceration pending bail? Again: I don't know, none of this really has easy yes/no answers.
- jaxn 8y agoWhat is and isn't a violent crime is already well-defined. Mugging is a violent crime, but shoplifting isn't. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violent_crime https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violent_crime
- woolvalley 8y agoThe thing is, I don't really care if people are using illegal substances or selling illegal services / objects between each other. But I get pretty pissed off when someone steals my bike, smashes my car, wakes me up in the middle of the night or similar. These are not necessarily violent, but they still are things I feel like we should prevent more than the other types.
- jaxn 8y agoThese issues with bonds have nothing to do with crime prevention. And whether or not you are pissed off has no bearing on how an innocent person should be treated. Oh, and in the US, every person is innocent until proven guilty in the court of law. So by definition, every bond is issued to an innocent person.
- olliej 8y agoBail does not effect your ability to track people - what tracking do you think it adds? Or do you mean the bit where bail ensure that all the arrested poor people are kept in jail?
- 0xffff2 8y ago>or you literally go to jail without a trial. You go to jail until your trial. Not quite the same thing.
- Guvante 8y agoBoth are true. You go to jail without a trial until your trial is done.
- ransom1538 8y ago"You go to jail until your trial." Uh. No one goes to 'trial' anymore.
- olliej 8y agoI go, lets say I'm arrested for some reason (wrong place wrong time, being at a protest, being the wrong colour for the neighborhood). Ican't afford bail, now I go to jail. 2 months later the charges are dropped. I spent two months in jail, I didn't even have a trial, so I wasn't even in jail "until my trial", I was jailed for no reason. That is enough to get me fired - I didn't come to work, and US law doesn't protect me from being fired when a court prevents me from going to work. The /only/ reasons for jail before trial is if there is a risk to the public or a documented risk of not appearing. The existing bail laws punish you according to what prosecution and police can get away with, and functionally turn "bail law" into jail for the non-rich, fines for the middle class. Maybe that could be reduced if the government were considered liable for any and all losses suffered by someone who is innocent, including loss of employment. That would given prosecutors and police some balance to the incentives to prevent bail or demand large bail amounts.
- trhway 8y agoYou go to jail and that makes you more pliable for a plea deal.