2 ms·
Well, Cyc comes from a somewhat different philosophical viewpoint. It is "commonsense reasoning" broadly, but its goal is more to encode "correct" knowledge for
by _delirium 16y ago
Well, Cyc comes from a somewhat different philosophical viewpoint. It is "commonsense reasoning" broadly, but its goal is more to encode "correct" knowledge for a whole range of basic things, rather than necessarily just common knowledge in the sense of knowledge that everyone has. Less "imitate humans" and more "analyze these domains correctly and consistently and encode them in the computer once and for all as a basic substrate on which other things can be built/learned".
Part of the reason for that approach is that it uses a fairly standard logic, in which you really need some consistency, contradictions are a problem, etc.; whereas if you were to just collect the sum of what the average people on the street think, there are a ton of inconsistencies, outright contradictions, omissions, illogical beliefs, etc., which you'd need a completely different model from standard logic to deal with.
It harkens back somewhat to the 19th-century dream of a "philosophy machine", where we'd formalize various kinds of concepts (Newtonian physics, different theories of causation, theories of time, etc.), then the computer could tell us which propositions are valid under which theories. So Cyc actually hires philosophers to encode some of its ontology, runs some things by physicists, etc. It's very much a non-psychological approach, attempting to build an ontology that in some sense is a "correct" representation of the world by consulting experts on each area to be formalized and making sure all the areas are consistent with each other.