3 ms·
From what I know of other cultures, the more appropriate question might be, "why do Americans resent upward mobility less than other cultures do?" See: In the
by gojomo 16y ago
From what I know of other cultures, the more appropriate question might be, "why do Americans resent upward mobility less than other cultures do?"
See:
In the rest of the English-speaking world, 'Tall poppy syndrome':
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tall_poppy_syndrome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tall_poppy_syndrome
In Japan, "the stake that sticks up gets hammered down" (though this may be more about nonconformity than success):
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_proverbs#Sayings http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_proverbs#Sayings
In Scandinavia, 'Jante Law':
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jante_Law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jante_Law
(American individualism, materialism, frontier-mythology, immigrant-mythology, and rootlessness are all potential explanations for a warmer appreciation of the idea of the 'self-made success'.)
- samfoo 16y agoI lived in New Zealand (as an American) and discovered Tall Poppy Syndrome while I was there: It drove me mad. Even talking about any of your successes is seen as ostentatious, regardless of the context. The article mystifies me from a global perspective. Americans to me seem obsessed with upward mobility. The "American Dream" is a dream of upward mobility, for goodness sake. Why do we resent taxes on the rich, even when we're poor? Because we expect one day that we might be that rich person. One's skin color or religion is largely irrelevant in the US compared with the amount of money that you have. This is not the truth in many places.
- arethuza 16y agoWhen you say "upward mobility" do you mean economic or social mobility (or both)? In the UK there is a non-trivial relationship between the two.
- samfoo 16y agoBoth. However, my only experience is with the west coast and my impression is that the east coast is different in some respects. On the west coast (in Seattle specifically -- but I believe the same holds true in LA or the bay area) nearly all money is new money, which forces social mobility to be tightly coupled with economic mobility. Another significant factor is that, culturally, Americans (in my experience) more closely associate wealth with success than any other nation and success correlates directly to social value (and mobility). While it might be possible to move up the economic rungs without moving up socially, it's not generally possible to move up the social ladder without correspondingly increasing your wealth. (Disclaimer: I'm not by any means a member of the social elite -- to the extent that such a thing exists in Seattle -- nor am I by any means "rich")