5 ms·
From the page, some open-source drama: > Salmon is a fork of Lamson. [...] Lamson was relicensed under a BSD variant that was revokable. [...] I read that to m
by wpietri 8y ago
From the page, some open-source drama:
> Salmon is a fork of Lamson. [...] Lamson was relicensed under a BSD variant that was revokable. [...] I read that to mean that I could make a contribution but then have said work denied to me because the orginal author didn’t like the colour of my socks. So I went and found the latest version that was available under the GNU GPL version 3.
Does anybody know the backstory here?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- m_eiman 8y agoI know that Zed Shaw wrote Lamson, but I know nothing about the drama.
- dna_polymerase 8y agoI don't think there was some drama between two people involved but the creator of salmon was afraid his license of Lamson could be revoked someday, just as the license states. In order to avoid this he forked an earlier version.
- mygo 8y agogood on him. there’s not many things to fear in this world but the prospect of someone having you by the balls is definitely one of them. well, unless you’re into that
- dec0dedab0de 8y agoNo, but the clause in that license is gross. He can sue any of his users at any time if he decides he doesn't want them to be his users anymore. It's by Zed Shaw author of Learn Python the Hard Way, I'm surprised by this. In any case it looks like Lamson has not been updated since 2013. The clause: The copyright holder reserves the right to revoke this license on anyone who uses this copyrighted work at any time for any reason.
- drharby 8y ago>I didnt think infinity wars was THAT good. REVOKED!
- dragonwriter 8y agoIronically, that clause might have no effect in US law; not because a license with it fails to be revocable, but because gratuitous licenses are revocable at will as a matter of law, anyway. (Then again, it might mitigate the likelihood that a court would limita the licensors recovery after revocation based on the principle of promissory estoppel.)
- ubernostrum 8y agoSection 2 of the GPLv3 explicitly declares itself irrevocable provided the terms are complied with. I said something similar about this the other day, but: for all the things I dislike about the GPL family of licenses, this is a fundamental design goal of the GPL: nobody, not even the original creator, is supposed to be able to pull the rug out from under you once you've received something under the GPL. If I had to guess, I'd guess that's why Salmon says it forked from a GPLv3 release of Lamson.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Section 2 of the GPLv3 explicitly declares itself irrevocable provided the terms are complied with. Yes, it does say that. That doesn't actually override a law which makes it revocable at will irrespective of it's terms—the license is governed by the law, not vice versa. Whether the GPLv3 is a gratuitous license probably depends on the circumstances of licensing in a particular case and not the text alone—its certainly possible for it to be a contract license instead, but it's not, AFAIK, clearly one in the general case.
- ubernostrum 8y agoLots of sites that handle user-generated content have, in their terms, an irrevocable license grant to allow them to reproduce and distribute your submitted content. Try revoking one of those and suing a site for infringement on grounds that it's impossible to grant an irrevocable license, and let me know how it turns out for you.
- carlosperate 8y agoNot the backstory, but some background: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4242786 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4242786 https://github.com/moggers87/salmon/issues/8 https://github.com/moggers87/salmon/issues/8