11 ms·
The problem with generative art is not that it isn’t considered art by everyone. The main problems are: - It is very difficult to value. One can’t see at a gla
by dahart 8y ago
The problem with generative art is not that it isn’t considered art by everyone. The main problems are:
- It is very difficult to value. One can’t see at a glance whether it took time or skill to create. And similar to other types of art that involve mechanical reproduction, e.g. photography, generative art can be produced on demand, it’s not irreplaceable like a sculpture or painting is.
- It usually lacks a good story. Getting attention in the art world may depend more on the artist’s narrative than on the art itself, and many art consumers will similarly buy when the story is right, and avoid art they love when it has a bad or boring story. I think people legitimately and reasonably need to be able to have something interesting to say when their friends comment on the artwork in their house.
I say this as a generative artist and absolute generative art lover myself. I explored what it might take to make a living from generative art for a year, and I’ve met a lot of people who hate all things digital, as well as a lot of people who get what I do and love it. The thing is, the people who hate it or don’t get it have a point.
> Myth Two: The artist has zero control and the autonomous machine is randomly generating the designs. The computer is making the art and the human deserves no credit, as it is not really art.
This one I’ve run into a lot. People who don’t think I deserve full credit, or just don’t know how to assign or think about credit.
> Myth One: The artist has complete control and the code is always executed exactly as written. Therefore, generative art lacks the elements of chance, accident, discovery, and spontaneity that often makes art great, if not at least human and approachable.
This one I haven’t seen much of, and I’d question whether it’s a common myth. But, more importantly, I cringe at the idea that randomness leads to discovery or spontaneity or human approachableness. I would never compare randomness to surprises or creativity in traditional art, but that idea is fairly pervasive among generative art initiates. I use randomness a lot, but randomness is very boring. It’s mechanical variety without surprise, randomness rarely leads to surprise without a lot of generative creativity on the part of the artist.
- tripzilch 8y ago> It usually lacks a good story. Then it's not generative art. Without the story, generative art is just procedural / computer generated art. And indeed because of the mass-production related reasons you name, that sort of art is less valuable. Because why this particular instance, this random seed, and not the billions of others giving rise to similar-yet-not-similar artworks that never were? Without the story of the process, there is no answer to this question and it diminishes the value of the art to something that simply "looks nice". Maybe the story is just "because the artist randomly saw this particular one out of billions and decided they liked it enough" -- which isn't the best story, IMHO. Generative art is really all about the process. You can have a camera on a plant, producing pseudo-random numbers that generate an image, video or sound. Now you have a story. You can do something similar but instead use the crowd of people walking past your art piece, and you have a different story. You can adapt the way it visualises so that it fits the story. But most importantly, you create a meaningful answer to the question "why this particular instantiation?" It goes as far that the visualisation (or audio or whatever) can be relatively simple or unoriginal as long as the story behind it is REALLY interesting, you've got a great piece of generative art. The reverse, however, is not. If you got a great visualisation, that is super intriguing to look at, yet the story behind it is merely an afterthought or almost non-existent, you've got a great piece of procedural / computer-generated art. It's not very good generative art if the process doesn't play a prominent role in the story. It might be nicer to look at, probably easier to sell because it looks nice and people are more likely to want to hang it on their walls. But making things because you want to sell them is craft (which is cool, if you want to make a living--of course you can do both). > many art consumers will similarly buy when the story is right, and avoid art they love when it has a bad or boring story What the hell is an "art consumer". If you want to sell something then yes, it's gotta have some utility value. That's what separates art from craft. I'm not sure how that's relevant. It sounds to me like your problem is with commercial exploitation of your art. There's a certain arrogance in the statement that "art consumers" will avoid art they love if it has a boring story. Who do you think you are to decide for your audience what art they "really love" and what not. If you mean that they avoid art that they find like really, really PRETTY, but then avoid it because there is no story and it's just one instance out of billions of random seeds and value it appropriately, then that's a pretty superficial way to look at what it means to "really love" a piece of art. Of course the story is important. The alternative is getting your craft up to the level that it outshines any possible lack of story.
- swatcoder 8y ago> The main problems are: Those are problems, but I think you're accidentally digging backwards to find them. If you want to make a living in art, selling to collectors and galleries, it's really not about pragmatic economic concerns like these. It's about having a community of patrons and collectors who can't help but talk about and trade the work at galleries and dinner parties. As that catches, people will inevitably surface the "good stories" and the reproduction of work will be managed in some way. That hasn't happened in a way that's been explosive yet. Once a few superstars wow the right people and see their work anchor major gallery collections, there'll be a lot more room for smaller artists. Personally, I wouldn't overthink the reasons why. Codifying them as "main problems" might just leave you missing opportunity when the winds change.
- dahart 8y ago> I think you’re accidentally digging backwards to find them. You might be completely right. Though I’m not sure I understand what you mean by digging backwards. The problems I see are, of course, the main problems I’ve personally run into. I have a hard time telling a compelling story to someone who doesn’t know anything about computers or math. When I look around, I can see that many other people have the same problem. My point was that generative art is and always has been considered art by some people, but it still has issues convincing traditional artists. > If you want to make a living in art, selling to collectors and galleries, it’s really not about pragmatic economic concerns like these Just curious - have you actually tried selling art? This might be extremely presumptuous, but your statement sounds like lack of experience. It’s almost entirely about pragmatic concerns, so much so that it becomes harder to make art when you need to make a living. There are millions of people trying to make it in the art world and failing. > It’s about having a community of patrons and collectors who can’t help but talk about and trade the work at galleries and dinner parties. I don’t mean this to be rude at all, but this is a pure fantasy. There are almost zero living artists who have this kind of following, the only ones who do are famous, and they didn’t have this before they were famous. > As that catches, people will inevitably surface the “good stories” That depends on you giving them the good stories, right? > Codifying them as “main problems” might just leave you missing opportunity when the winds change. You might be right, point taken. They’re my “main problems”, and not necessarily yours or the future’s. However, if you look around, you’ll see that the problems I called out have been problems for a long time, and they are problems with other genres too. Photography is also harder to value, because of it’s reproducibility, which is why it has never (yet) reached quite the same status as a Rembrandt painting or a Michelangelo sculpture. Hopefully you’re right and in the future, we can value the creativity itself, rather than the object.
- js8 8y agoI think people who don't consider it being art do not understand that part of the art is the interpretation that happens in the spectator's mind. Dan Dennett has a beautiful example in his talk on consciousness (https://www.ted.com/talks/dan_dennett_on_our_consciousness/transcript https://www.ted.com/talks/dan_dennett_on_our_consciousness/t...), where he talks about the Bellotto's painting. "But, more importantly, I cringe at the idea that randomness leads to discovery or spontaneity or human approachableness." I am not sure I completely agree with that. See this presentation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dXQPL9GooyI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dXQPL9GooyI
- dahart 8y agoThanks for the video, I’ll watch it later this morning. It’s totally okay to disagree with me, but FWIW, there’s a big difference in my mind between arbitrary and random, or between accident and random, or between discovery and random. A uniform random variable has an expected value, a guaranteed average, and known bounds, so to frame it according to that video, using a random number generator is designed and planned, and it won’t lead to anything happening that you didn’t expect. You can’t predict each instance, but you can predict the behavior. So I’m saying I already buy the title of that video (“Why greatness can’t be planned”) but I don’t think rand() is a vehicle to get you there.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- codingdave 8y ago> The problem with generative art is not that it isn’t considered art by everyone. Abstract Art in general isn't considered "Art" by everyone, especially in the days of Abstract Expressionism and Jackson Pollack. While I do appreciate the thoughts around generative art, these discussions are not new. But it is a new generation using new tools, re-discovering the arguments from the mid 20th century. The question isn't whether it is art, or whether other people think it is art. The question is why do those questions matter to you (the generic you, not OP or any specific commenter) as an artist. Are you doing it to get validation from others? Are you doing it to sell the work to others? Or do you have your own reasons for your work, aside from the opinions of others? For me, art is about self expression and self exploration. If other people call it "art", great. If they buy my work, even better. But I'll do my work, either way.
- monfera 8y agoGood points. A minor thing, generative art isn't necessarily abstract art, though currently almost exclusively is. (Oh and spelled Pollock.) Regarding validation, it might not matter for some, but might for others. I'm sure there were quite a few great artists who wouldn't have done their art at the same level had there not been validation as art. Something more mundane, recognition is likely a big factor in whether patrons seek out and are willing to pay for generative art. So it can matter even for those who aren't looking for the ego lifting part.
- tripzilch 8y ago> A minor thing, generative art isn't necessarily abstract art, though currently almost exclusively is. Thank you. There's a lot of people throwing around art terminology in this thread and it doesn't always make sense. Generative art only has to output through a photorealistic renderer and suddenly it's no longer "abstract", but "surrealism". This demonstrates how little sense it makes to apply such terms to generative art. Let alone the fact that it's multimedia and the term really only applies to visual art. You could have "abstract music", I guess, but it means something completely different. It's an interesting discussion though.
- 8y ago
- tokyodude 8y agoI also love generative art ... mostly .... and I've made quite a bit but ....... The problem I have is generally when it appears to me it didn't require much effort. Making a program that draws random dots, random rectangles, random lines, is almost a rite of passage for new programmers. A lot of generative art looks like hardly many more steps beyond that. Draw 100 rectangle each slightly smaller and rotated from the previous and you get a beautiful spiral. I know my own rarely take more than 30 minutes each. I just take some existing generator and start tweaking. If I get something mildly pleasing I save it. But I rarely promote it because I feel at some level it was farted out, it was a sketch, a doodle, not a "work" of art. Of course I know effort is probably not a valid criteria but still, it's sometimes hard not to see what appears to be low-effort generative art as barely more than the random dot/line/rectangle exercise most programmers do early in their learning. Like instead of 100% random colors use HSL and only vary the values 10% from some initial value and suddenly it's "art". (pick light blue and it's snow on the ground, pick light brown and it's sand, pick green and it's grass, pick red/orange/yellow and it's lava). It makes it hard to know when it crossed the line from learning to code to "art". Of course like I said I still appreciate generative art but for some reason my own block is that I need to perceive effort. It can even be simple but I have to look at it and think something like "That was simple but took a long time to find the right parameters to get it to look that pleasing". Let me add, it's a pie in the sky dream of mine to have/run/start/manage a kinetic interactive art museum the size of the Exploritorium in SF with constantly new exhibits much of which would be generative art.
- tripzilch 8y agoI understand your problem and I agree it is hard. But consider for a moment the type of paintings that make people go "my 3 year old niece could do this". If you don't know the artist, know nothing about their intents and method of work, really how do you tell the difference between certain styles and that of a child or amateur? How do you tell the difference between a Mondriaan and somebody's first graphics coding exercise?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- zwkrt 8y ago
- kowdermeister 8y ago> The problem with generative art is There are no problems. It's just another art form. > I’ve met a lot of people who hate all things digital, as well as a lot of people who get what I do and love it So just ignore them. There is always an audience who will appreciate your work. > I explored what it might take to make a living from generative art I'm doing that currently as well, but I think it always will be my side project. If it pays the rent, I'll be more than happy :)
- dahart 8y ago> There are no problems. It's just another art form. :) You are right, of course. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The "problems" I list are based on unspoken assumptions about what the goal is. > So just ignore them. There is always an audience who will appreciate your work. Totally agree, and ignoring them is an option. I'm personally interested in hearing out the haters and learning what valuable lessons are there. Partly this comes from finding out that my story just isn't compelling to people who don't know any programming or math, and wanting to learn how to craft a story that is compelling to more people.
- kowdermeister 8y agoI feel it's the same with music. You can't really 'tune' a Katy Perry song more to appeal a classic music lover and vice versa. > my story just isn't compelling to people who... Your work should tell a story, and the method of creation is secondary. I totally appreciate if you used equations I can't even grasp, but my mother shouldn't know about that at all and she can still consider it nice. There was a guy who posted here on HN, he used machine learning to create art and his mistake was that he revealed his method, the magic was gone, since it was not obvious how it was made. I'm not a great artist or anything, I just see a pattern that art that grabs people's attention has some kind of message or relevance to the current age.
- artgen 8y ago> Your work should tell a story No, that's nonsense. Tons of art throughout history told no story and was still compelling. Pollock, Balanchine, Schoenberg, etc. did abstract works that tell no story. (In fact, Balanchine specifically made it a point to not have a story.)
- lancesells 8y agoI think the point about value / story / theme is the same in all mediums of art. I'm a traditional artist and I can tell you there are a million oil painters out there producing work that no one will pay money for or consider valuable. Personally, I think there's a market for generative art out there but it'll be the 1% that you'll hear about and it will take the right blend of personality, aesthetics, theme, and timing to get right.
- skybrian 8y agoThe "difficult to value" part seems like a problem for artists and the art business rather than for art appreciation? I suppose Patreon might help to some extent? It can be used to fund the artist rather than buying (and therefore needing to value) specific items. To some extent, "generated by computer science techniques" seems like an interesting story? Maybe understanding how computer programs are designed and used is a specialized taste.
- tlarkworthy 8y agoFor a broad definition of generative art, computer games. These are wildly popular I hear.