4 ms·
> If it were actually more valuable then someone would buy the company, fire the noblesse oblige and hire new management. Comical. "The Market" is far from per
by AlexandrB 8y ago
> If it were actually more valuable then someone would buy the company, fire the noblesse oblige and hire new management.
Comical. "The Market" is far from perfect - especially in more monopolized industries. Consider the 2008 housing crash for a recent[1] example where "the market" did not behave rationally across a wide swath of professional investors. Add to that the fact that the "someone" in your example is most likely part of the noblesse oblige themselves and will default to respecting the opinion of the board (no matter how wrong) and not the workers.
> If the “happy workers make more money for the company” truly had a positive ROI, then the market would pay it.
Most often, the market behaves like a gradient descent algorithm - seeking slightly more optimal operating conditions without rocking the boat too much. This normally leads to finding local minima, not global ones. The most notable exception is "startups", where the initial conditions of the search may be radically different than a typical big-co - sometimes leading to better results.
Now consider that most medium-to-large companies have been operating for years (maybe decades) on the assumption that cutting costs - including wages - is the best way incrementally optimize profit. Reversing direction would mean going back uphill for a while as the culture, employee attitudes, and recruitment pipeline slowly change in response. How many boards do you think would put up with years of declining profits during the attempt to find the better way?
This doesn't mean that there aren't examples of companies that take this approach even for low-skilled labor[2][3]. Just that it's rare because of conventional wisdom and the corporate politics involved in making it happen.
[1] An even more recent example is Theranos - where companies that should have known better bet big on partnerships with a vaporware medical company against the explicit advice of consultants they had hired to advise them on these matters.
[2] https://www.businessinsider.com/costco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10 https://www.businessinsider.com/costco-pays-retail-employees...
[3] http://brandautopsy.com/2007/01/the_starbucks_e.html http://brandautopsy.com/2007/01/the_starbucks_e.html