4 ms·
Maybe they just would pull money away from shareholders and executives in the form of pay raises and better benefits for senior employees, particularly the ones
by philwelch 8y ago
Maybe they just would pull money away from shareholders and executives in the form of pay raises and better benefits for senior employees, particularly the ones who run the union (https://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines https://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines). Also, by enforcing a closed shop, they could simultaneously pull money away from lower level employees, in the form of union dues, and funnel it to the benefit of the people who run the union. Sometimes they even funnel the money to the Mafia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Hoffa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Hoffa).
The moral hazards inherent in a "handful of powerful leaders who represent the interests of $GROUP" doesn't change much when $GROUP is "workers" instead of "shareholders". Executives and union organizers are often two sides of the same coin in that respect.
- eseehausen 8y agoExcept the groups they represent are different. Executives represent the shareholders and labor organizers represent labor. Even if you say a large part of the benefits are lost due to corruption in both cases, it shapes where the remainder ends up.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> labor organizers represent labor. Unions claim to represent labor, but due to a confluence of laws, there's no guarantee that they actually do, as pointed out above. Even within a union, politics exists, and those who are influential and important are able to extract resources away from those who are viewed as dispensible.
- refurb 8y agoNot sure why you’re being downvoted. You last sentence is true for any human organization. Politics exist and those with power sometimes take from those who don’t. That includes unions.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Except the groups they represent are different. Executives represent the shareholders and labor organizers represent labor. Even if you say a large part of the benefits are lost due to corruption in both cases, it shapes where the remainder ends up. But you have to compare it to the alternative. The question is whether the incremental amount the union gets from management over what the employee would have gotten for themselves is more than the overhead/corruption cost of the union. For shareholders of public companies there is little choice. If you own $1000 each worth of a hundred different companies, you're not going to have the time or incentive to manage them all properly yourself (and neither is any other individual shareholder), so the benefit of hiring a board to do it is worth the cost. The math is a lot different when you only have one employer and you're getting ~100% of your income from them. In that case people have a strong incentive to do their own research and try to get the best possible employment for themselves. It's the same reason most companies with a single owner are owner-operated. About the only thing a union is going to get you is leveraging its monopoly power, which only works against monopolistic employers that have enough margins to pay you more without themselves becoming uncompetitive and also individually represent too much of the industry to just let everyone walk out and hire all different low level employees. This is why, for example, unions worked well for workers in the dominant era of the Big Three American auto companies, and much less well now that they have aggressive competition from Japan, Germany and Korea. But their cars are a lot better now. A lot more people died back then. Other people wrote scathing books and passed new laws. Uncompetitive markets are terrible.
- geezerjay 8y ago> and labor organizers represent labor. Actually they don't. They either represent a political organization or some other interest group. The workers only take a passive role in the whole process.
- Frondo 8y agoThis is a misleading statement. Labor organizers represent a labor union that's trying to organize those workers -- usually with the goal of having that newly established union join up with the union the labor organizers represent, but they never have to. The new union could join up with any other, or set off on their own. Saying "a political organization" is misleading because it evokes an image of a super-PAC or something else overtly political, and saying "some other interest group" glosses over the reality that, yes, you could call unions interest groups that represent their workers for collective bargaining, but again, that's misleading. The fair way to phrase this is "Labor organizers represent a union that's trying to unionize a new workplace," but that obviously sounds less sketchy. And the workers take a verrrrry active role in the process, especially any that become involved in the organizing themselves, up to and including being fired (illegally, because firing someone for labor-related activities is not allowed). * Not a union member, but I hate seeing anti-union and anti-labor tropes trotted out, especially on a group that usually prides itself on accuracy.
- philwelch 8y agoMost of the big unions conspicuously operate as overtly political organizations these days.
- gowld 8y agoAnd yet society and government generally tolerates this behavior from executives and prosecute union leaders.
- philwelch 8y agoCan you name a single executive who mysteriously disappeared after a long history of involvement with organized crime?
- cannonedhamster 8y agoYou're kind of proving their point. Labor has historically been a government and capital versus the employed. How many times has the national guard been called to quell an executive uprising? None because executives always hold the power and moneyed interests always run the government. The only change in this in the US was the brief history after WW2 where FDR and Truman wielded outsize political power and the country saw the ills of the gilded age because of the enormous impact felt by the average person during the great depression. To answer your question directly there are most definitely executives tied to organized crime. Organized crime is more organized now and less violent. The Sopranos is basically based on this. The industries that organized crime generally controls are blue collar industries. People don't need to disappear anymore, they just look like regular deaths.
- philwelch 8y ago> How many times has the national guard been called to quell an executive uprising? None because executives always hold the power and moneyed interests always run the government. I think it's more because the national guard is only necessary to suppress large-scale riots, and there aren't enough executives all in the same place to make even a small-scale riot. Executives who are charged with crimes can be individually arrested. But all of that is beside the point, because I'm comparing union leaders and organizers with executives. > The only change in this in the US was the brief history after WW2 where FDR and Truman wielded outsize political power and the country saw the ills of the gilded age because of the enormous impact felt by the average person during the great depression. This completely misses the more relevant fact that the US represented 50% of the global economy at the time (due to every other industrialized nation being absolutely devastated by the war) and reinvested much of their remaining wealth into rebuilding both their allies and their former adversaries, which led to an unsustainable period of "catch-up" economic growth that faded just as soon as the Germans and Japanese started doing a better job at manufacturing than the US did. > To answer your question directly there are most definitely executives tied to organized crime. Citation needed.
- M2Ys4U 8y agoHow about simply making closed-shop unions illegal? That's how things work in the UK.