3 ms·
I wrote the following as part of an email to the USPTO when it was requesting comments for Bilski Guidance a few weeks ago. I threw it together on the last day
by SkyMarshal 16y ago
I wrote the following as part of an email to the USPTO when it was requesting comments for Bilski Guidance a few weeks ago. I threw it together on the last day so it's not entirely well thought out, but I'm curious what's the HN take on the general idea of such a framework like this:
"One framework for thinking about software patents is the
Edison Criteria - inspiration vs perspiration. Thomas Edison said:
'None of my inventions came by accident. I see a worthwhile need to be met and I make trial after trial until it comes. What it boils down to is one per cent inspiration and ninety-nine per cent perspiration.'
This statement illuminates the fact that there are several domains under which inventions can be categorized:
1. Easy/inexpensive to derive, and easy/inexpensive to implement or produce (ex: Amazon 1-click check out)
2. Easy/inexpensive to derive, and difficult/costly to implement or produce (Google Search)
3. Difficult/costly to derive, easy/inexpensive to implement or produce (pharmaceuticals)
4. Difficult/costly to derive, difficult/costly to implement or produce (Saturn V rocket, Large Hadron Collider)
Easy and difficult are, of course, relative values, and there are certainly grey areas in between, not every invention or innovation falls neatly within one of these criteria. However, if the objective of the patent system is to promote the progress of science and useful arts, then I suggest the PTO allow patents only for #3 and #4, but not
for #1 and #2."
The idea is that #1 is obvious and easy - others would likely come up with the idea independently and implement it, creating competition, improvement, and falling prices. Patenting inventions in this area would hence harm progress in the 'useful arts'.
#2 has a natural moat (cost of implementation) and hence does not need additional protection from patents, and may fail the obviousness test anyway.
#3 is costly to derive and has no natural moat (as demonstrated by the generic drug industry) and hence needs additional patent protection to preserve the incentive to make the large investments required for progress in this domain.
#4 is both costly and has a natural moat, and I'm not entirely sure how patents should apply here, but it's not relevant to issue of software patents and Bilski.
What do you guys think of categorizing inventions/knowledge like this for purposes of deciding what can be patented or not?
- Vivtek 16y agoIf it's difficult to derive and produce, you're not likely to need patent protection. Patenting a large hadron collider would be money and thought wasted - it's a unique undertaking and people will come to you to use it anyway. The bleeping 1-click patent, though, God, it's enough to make my head explode if I think too much about that being patented. An utter perversion of the original intent of the patent system.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoYeah, Amazon 1-click was the public start of the insanity. Peer-to-Patent formalization just can't come fast enough, it's a great idea. And under this framework, difficult to derive implies a need for patent protection, in order to prevent one entity from piggybacking off the derivation work and investment of another. But difficult to implement implies a lack of need for patent protection due to an implementation moat/barrier. Combine the two, and it gets into gray areas. I used the LHC as an extreme example, but I can imagine other less extreme examples of #4 where the patentability is not so clear. Say, quantum processors - lots of time and research is going into deriving them, and they certainly won't be easy or cheap to produce, but the payoff may mitigate the implementation/production cost and be particularly attractive to some company looking to piggyback off the derivation work/expense of another.