2 ms·
Just have the candidates use their own machines. We tried inviting candidates to bring their own laptops, and it turns out often they didn't _have_ laptops - o
by michaelt 8y ago
Just have the candidates use their own machines.
We tried inviting candidates to bring their own laptops, and it turns out often they didn't _have_ laptops - or we'd tell them there was a Java-based test and (perhaps due to a miscommunication or because this is an uncommon interview practice) they'd arrive with a laptop without a working Java VM or compiler.
Needless to say, you can't objectively compare two candidates' progress if one of them spends half the interview trying to get their environment set up!
Regarding security practices... come on. [...]
These are simple engineering problems.
Perhaps I wasn't clear: My employer is a medium-sized company, and consequentially IT security is actually a complex political problem rather than a simple engineering problem.
You've also made a pretty big shift in the goalposts there, from asking "why don't companies have candidates accomplish the thing they're assessing?" to asking "why don't companies have candidates accomplish the thing they're assessing, and perform remote video interviews, and have the ability to give spin up clean AWS environments and give remote semi-trusted interview candidates access to them?"
- tptacek 8y agoIf you insist on doing the interview in person, why not just tell them ahead of time what their environment needs to do when they get there? Give people instructions and a script (formal or just a numbered list of steps) that determines they're ready to go. Better yet, just don't make people do that stuff in your office. Why bother videorecording interviews at all? I'd have problems writing a line of code with someone breathing down my neck. If you did it to me on the job, I'd chase you out of the room. I feel like a lot of these problems are, like I said, unforced. Agree to disagree about the degree of difficulty of getting clean environments to candidates. You're either serious about recruiting as an engineering problem or you're not. "Not" is fine, but then don't pretend like there's some kind of rigor in deciding which corners you're willing to cut. I'm not making this stuff up; this is how we've been hiring people for about 10 years now, and every time I hear someone explain how challenging or untenable our process is, I keep wondering, "what am I doing wrong to make this work so well for us?"
- michaelt 8y agoWhy bother videorecording interviews at all? We don't record interviews. By "remote video interviews" I meant "remote interviews by videoconferencing such as Skype or Google Hangouts" which I assumed was what you meant when you proposed candidates use their own office or couch. why not just tell them ahead of time what their environment needs to do when they get there? We did this, including a github test project they could check out and build to make sure everything was working. Still, about 50% of candidates arrived without a working environment. We chose to supply a known-good laptop instead of rejecting such candidates instantly when they've spent time travelling to us etc. every time I hear someone explain how challenging or untenable our process is, I keep wondering, "what am I doing wrong to make this work so well for us?" I'm not saying your process is challenging for _you_ given _your_ situation; I'm sure it works very well for you! I'm saying it's challenging for _us_ given _our_ situation :)
- tptacek 8y agoMaybe I'm being unclear. I'm asking: why does there need to be video or telephonic oversight of any sort for a work-sample challenge? Why are you assigning yourself that problem? We've never done that and never had a problem.
- michaelt 8y agoAh, you mean a take-home test? Some people involved in our hiring process don't like them, they say experienced candidates stop responding when sent take-home tests. Their theory is employed people with families don't have the time - although we don't have hard empirical evidence for this for obvious reasons.
- tptacek 8y agoPeople don't do take-home tests because companies give them in addition to interview loops. I'm saying, just do the at-home test, and cut out the interviews.
- shady-lady 8y ago> Needless to say, you can't objectively compare two candidates' progress if one of them spends half the interview trying to get their environment set up! If most of the issues revolve around having roughly the same environment for candidates, just create ready to go VM images, for example VirtualBox, and share that with them. Or use a cloud desktop VM. All of which make it easier for someone to succeed.