3 ms·
I'm not a fan of UBI, but arguing against $1,000 per person seems like a bit of a strawman. For a 4 person family that's $4,000 take home per month, which is w
by jandrese 8y ago
I'm not a fan of UBI, but arguing against $1,000 per person seems like a bit of a strawman. For a 4 person family that's $4,000 take home per month, which is well above median income for the US when you factor in taxes and benefits. This strongly encourages people to pump out kids for the stipend.
Doesn't it make more sense to make it $1,000 per household + $100/person?
IMHO UBI fails for one basic human reason: people are lazy. Way too many people would sit around all day watching TV if they didn't have to go to work. There would be a labor shortage. This only works in some future where we have robots to do literally every menial job. Even then it's still likely a bad idea from a mental health perspective. People without a sense of purpose or accomplishment are going to become depressed, and self starters are the exception not the rule.
- philwelch 8y ago> I'm not a fan of UBI, but arguing against $1,000 per person seems like a bit of a strawman. For a 4 person family that's $4,000 take home per month, which is well above median income for the US when you factor in taxes and benefits. This strongly encourages people to pump out kids for the stipend. Doesn't it make more sense to make it $1,000 per household + $100/person? The average cost of raising a child is about $1000 per month, and though it would probably be less if you're destitute enough to subsist off of UBI, I'm not sure that having even more kids is a winning move. The Child Tax Credit is more than $1000 already. But it looks like children are 25% of the US population, and reducing the expenditure by another 25% doesn't really make a huge dent, to be honest.
- kwhitefoot 8y ago> UBI fails for one basic human reason: people are lazy. Not true. The few real studies of basic income all demonstrate that people, on the whole, do not stop working.
- jandrese 8y agoThe studies of northern European middle class families?
- kwhitefoot 8y agoNo, studies of Canadian and US working class towns.