3 ms·
Yes, I did acknowledge the possibility of long tail costs being higher. A case of money being owed should be relatively simple to substantiate, and if the amoun
by mindslight 8y ago
Yes, I did acknowledge the possibility of long tail costs being higher. A case of money being owed should be relatively simple to substantiate, and if the amount is that well defined, then I'd think attorney's fees would be awarded when the other side didn't accept your offer to take $20k and insisted on litigation. But obviously many types of contracts would love to write "you cannot sue us for any reason whatsoever", and yet this is not allowed - even though it would make a lot of sense for many things like no-economic-consideration software licenses (rather than that whole NO WARRANTY rigmarole).
The main problem, as I focused on, is malinterpretation.
My example had to be very unsubtle to be understood, which is the norm in software land. But yes my contrived example would not pass the smell test in legal land and would thus be easily contested. So now we get to argue about the epsilon. Directly from the article you linked:
> Crucially, these grounds do not include substantive review of the award for "mere" errors of law or fact. As a result, "judicial review of arbitration decisions is among the narrowest known to the law."
It seems like one would likely have to show an overt conspiracy with the arbitrator or other gross arbitrary behavior to contest a decision. Given how much corruption is based on cooperative wink-wink, and that the contract drafter/arbitrator purchaser is likely to be the repeat customer, it's a bad setup.
Also directly from that article:
> Before the enactment of the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) and its Florida counterpart, the Florida Arbitration Code (FAC), courts were generally hostile to arbitration, viewing it as "an attempt to oust courts of [their] lawful jurisdiction."
So yes, it seems that the courts even agree with me. Then the arbitration industry got the ear of lawmakers, who proceeded to undermine the courts.
Don't get me wrong - philosophically I would very much like to reduce court costs and lawyer overhead. Stripping away the right to sue through contracts of adhesion is not the way to go about that though.