3 ms·
> Your statement implies that the Intel engineers have left a lot of design on the table. The Mill folks would rather argue that Intel's problem is they aren't
by wtallis 8y ago
> Your statement implies that the Intel engineers have left a lot of design on the table.
The Mill folks would rather argue that Intel's problem is they aren't leaving things on the table—instead, they're shoving tons of extra machinery into their core designs while the Mill tries to avoid extremely power-hungry performance enhancing techniques like speculative out of order execution.
> graph the active area vs power consumed for all the chips of a particular technology node
Setting aside the difficulties of accounting for differences between different manufacturer's processes at the same node, this still isn't a very informative measure. Active areas of the chip don't all make the same contribution to performance. Speculative execution can light up a lot of silicon executing instructions that don't actually need to be executed.
I'm quite skeptical that the Mill guys will ever produce a core that beats Intel on raw performance, but they have plenty of convincing arguments for why their power consumption will be much lower, and I think it's plausible that they will be able to beat Intel on performance per watt for some workloads.
- bsder 8y ago> Mill tries to avoid extremely power-hungry performance enhancing techniques like speculative out of order execution. Go look at Alpha 21164 vs x86 in the timeframe. You don't save as much as you think (and Intel's designs were much shoddier back then). > Setting aside the difficulties of accounting for differences between different manufacturer's processes at the same node, this still isn't a very informative measure. You would think so, but the graph is remarkably consistent. Just because a measure has noise does not make it a useless measure. Intel could be significantly below the curve. But beating the curve is ferociously difficult.