3 ms·
I clicked through expecting to be disappointed... but by golly, there's something to this. An imminent, disproportionate late-fee can make a less-than-even chan
by gojomo 16y ago
I clicked through expecting to be disappointed... but by golly, there's something to this. An imminent, disproportionate late-fee can make a less-than-even chance of instant liquidity more valuable than a more-than-even chance of larger loss.
Of course, assuming any reasonable credit is available at all, and that the person is not in permanent deficit unable to eventually pay back a loan, would give rise to a dominant option C, where enough is borrowed to avoid the penalty. But maybe this same effect is what makes 'payday' loans at astronomical effective rates attractive to some people.
Is there some other 'guardian angel' business model possible from this effect -- protecting the liquidity-challenged from disproportionate late fees, via an automatic loan of just-enough to save the fee, splitting the savings with the affected person?
As in: seconds before BofA or some other institution is about to pillage someone for $30, the 'angel' swoops in with a just-in-time loan, charging the person (in fees and interest) any amount less than $30 -- and lower with more competition.
- jrockway 16y agoAs in: seconds before BofA or some other institution is about to pillage someone for $30, the 'angel' swoops in with a just-in-time loan, charging the person (in fees and interest) any amount less than $30 -- and lower with more competition. It's called a credit card or savings account. If you have a credit card, you can't overdraw it. Or you can link your checking account to it, avoiding the "we're loaning you money even though you didn't ask for it" fee. Or you can have a savings account, and dip into that when your checking account runs out of money. Or you can just not run out of money. I got hit with an overdraft fee back when I was in college even though I explicitly opted out. I didn't make that mistake again. I stopped using a debit card and started using a credit card again... and now I even get 1.5% cash back. (If this happened to me now, I would have just filed a complaint with the state's attorneys general office. Customer service doesn't want to help? Enjoy the fine and new regulations.)
- gojomo 16y agoYes -- that's what someone who's on the ball does, using a short-term/reasonably-priced source of extra funds to avoid late fees. The theory of the 'guardian angel' service is that it handles things even when you forget. It presupposes that there's some way to give the service total visibility into your imminent payment deadlines -- of course right now that doesn't exist, and the businesses that rely on late fees for their margin may not want it to. But this might be an appropriate area for an industry consortium or even regulation to create a clearinghouse. If you're about to fine someone $X for an amount due up to $Y, you have to broadcast it on some confidential national clearinghouse an hour before assessment, allowing a contracted representative of the target to settle it on their behalf. If you do this, your fine is considered reasonable and customary; if you don't, it's presumed to be trickery and held to a higher standard. I agree it's farfetched. But when we're talking contrived scenarios where people living hand-to-mouth should play roulette, the imagination wanders!
- jrockway 16y agoSo this service is for someone who can't sign up for a credit card, but can sign up for a service that reads their bank account, anticipates future purchases, and tries to keep the balance up? Yeah. But this might be an appropriate area for an industry consortium or even regulation to create a clearinghouse. If you're about to fine someone $X for an amount due up to $Y, you have to broadcast it on some confidential national clearinghouse an hour before assessment, allowing a contracted representative of the target to settle it on their behalf. If you do this, your fine is considered reasonable and customary; if you don't, it's presumed to be trickery and held to a higher standard. Who pays for this? What's the penalty for "trickery"?
- gojomo 16y agoThe penalty? You're more likely to lose class action lawsuits like the ones that have recently stung some banks, or you're fined by regulators directly. Compared to electronic stock markets, or check/charge clearing, or even the Twitter firehose, this "identity M is about to be fined $N" live book is pretty simple. The 'angels' or regulators could pay for the system, but those who wish to assess late fines would be responsible for their own prompt reporting. For example, the law might be: "To charge a late fee that represents an effective interest rate more than 10 times the prime rate, electronic notices of intent-to-charge must be filed both 1 day and 1 hour before assessment, and electronic payment from third parties must be accepted."