3 ms·
Unions protect incumbent workers against new entrants. That's obviously great for you if you're personally an incumbent worker in an industry that's unionizing,
by closeparen 8y ago
Unions protect incumbent workers against new entrants. That's obviously great for you if you're personally an incumbent worker in an industry that's unionizing, but can't move the needle on the economy as a whole. As price rises, quantity demanded drops.
- noobermin 8y agoI hear this often but have never seen hard evidence of it working, unlike the OP who shows data which gives hard evidence. BTW, I've seen enough handwaving and half-truths about unions peddled by those trying to further degrade them I've stopped seeing arguments against unions as being in good faith.
- closeparen 8y agoHard evidence of closed shops and hiring halls existing? Hard evidence of supply and demand dynamics? This is not an argument for or against unions. As I mentioned, it’s likely in your personal interest to unionize if you can.
- aerotwelve 8y agoClosed shops are illegal in America and have been since the 1950s. Because of this, an employer never is forced to hire from a hiring hall (though many choose to do so because the union often contributes to the cost of recruitment and training these candidates).
- icantdrive55 8y agoI've heard this too, but never seen any evidence. The only good jobs I have had were unionized. The worst jobs were all non-union. Employers got around unions by moving factories overseas. Movies like Norma Rae could not be made today. Fat Cats got real slick. That said, some jobs just can't be shipped overseas. And many of those jobs are perfect for unionization. (I won't be back to debate. Too tired, but I will never understand how unions got such a bad rap, especially among the under thirty crowd? I guarantee working one day on a non-union construction site will have the most ardent anti-union bloke singing a new tune the following day.)
- baq 8y agounions are an organization that can, if it's working properly (big if), stand on equal grounds with HR - and probably the only organization that won't get all of its workers-members fired the moment the company realizes what's going on. sometimes.