5 ms·
But companies can't increase wages if it makes them uncompetitive. I think a huge downward pressure on wages is the fact that more industries have moved into "w
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
But companies can't increase wages if it makes them uncompetitive. I think a huge downward pressure on wages is the fact that more industries have moved into "winner take all" economics, so all of the also-rans face immense pressure to keep costs down in an attempt to compete.
Consider the bloodbath in retail. Amazon possesses so many structural advantages at this point that other retail companies are forced to do everything they can to keep costs low. A raise in wages could very easily make them even more uncompetitive with Amazon.
- alex_anglin 8y agoConversely, not having appropriate, enough or under-skilled employees makes them uncompetitive as well. In retail, consider Costco, who are known for paying decent wages and benefits. As a result of that, they have less shrink/theft and are able to compete. In technology, consider any big name tech firm. Chances are they understand what skills they need to be competitive and are willing to pay for them - creating upwards pressure for tech folks.
- nicoburns 8y agoWhich is the hidden downside of free market economics. It incentivises exactly this kind of cost cutting, even when it isn't beenficial to society.
- refurb 8y agoDownside? We wouldn’t have the level of wealth today if we didn’t become more efficient in our production (I.e. lower cost).
- rainonmoon 8y agoThe level of wealth we have is disproportionately assigned to the minority of people best able to exploit the majority of people. Obviously we can go back and forth on the specifics of how the world's current state of prosperity has benefits and harms, but to present that level of wealth as intrinsically beneficial is disingenuous.
- refurb 8y agoYou didn’t address my point at all. You claimed that “cost efficies” are a negative about capitalism and I said that’s the reason why level of wealth has changed increased dramatically even for the lowest rung. Just because it’s disproportionate doesn’t mean my statement isn’t true.
- rco8786 8y agoYour points are not mutually exclusive. The efficiencies are a large part of the reason we’ve collectively grown our wealth. They also are at times not the most advantageous to our society.
- nicoburns 8y agoRight, that's the upside: cost cutting by means of more efficient production. This can often be good. But not all cost cutting is equal. Say for example if a company cuts their costs by lobbying for lower taxes on the product that they sell. This could well be harmful to society, but is still incentivised in our economy. We need more nuance in our policy than "always incentivise lower prices".
- malandrew 8y agoBut it is beneficial to society. It keeps prices low and accessible. What good are increasing wages if it is accompanied by inflation that negates those increases? The truth is that the minimum wage worker today is able to purchase a LOT more than they could in the past. The only two costs that have gone up disproportionately are housing and healthcare. The former is due to bad government policy that encourages homeownership as an investment. The latter is due to cost disease.
- aperrien 8y agoExcept for rent, which shows no sign of stopping it's climb in cities and their associated suburbs.
- malandrew 8y agoRent is also tied to bad housing policy that prevents building.
- nawitus 8y agoThe housing market is hardly an example of free market economics.
- AstralStorm 8y agoSo, what is the example then? Personally, I think free market belongs to a class of spherical cow models.
- User23 8y ago> The truth is that the minimum wage worker today is able to purchase a LOT more than they could in the past. Except for energy, housing, health care, and education. But besides that sure, android phones are cheap!
- manfredo 8y agoHousing, healthcare, and education are expensive because of increased demand and unwillingness or inability to expand supply (e.g. restrictions on building denser housing in a lot of desirable areas, strong social pressure to get a 4 year education). Some of them are actually exacerbated by public involvement - easy access to credit for education means universities can charge a lot more. It's not just electronics that are cheaper. Things we take for granted now - owning a refrigerator, a car, heck even things like electricity and plumbing - were out of reach for many people a matter of decades ago. Sure many of these things were made in good old 'Murica back then and created low-skilled jobs - but these products also cost a much larger percentage of the average household's available income. You're also ignoring the immense benefit that free global markets provide for countries other those in the First World. China's shift to a free market economy singlehandedly halved global poverty. We tend to index heavily on the American that needs to change fields when his job is "shipped overseas". Rarely do litanies against free markets consider those overseas - almost always in a more precarious financial position than the country that is losing low skilled jobs - who get a chance to improve their lives due to free global markets.
- noobermin 8y agoWhat did the larger corporations widely do after Trump's taxcuts? Invest heavily in stock buy backs. They have the means to pay their workers more, they just don't want to. Also, they "can't increase wages if it makes them uncompetitive" doesn't square with "Everything Is Booming[...]" bit.