3 ms·
On a related note: How do you negotiate for a pay increase when the pay increase is controlled centrally? Every year my increase is not negotiable because it h
by dijit 8y ago
On a related note:
How do you negotiate for a pay increase when the pay increase is controlled centrally? Every year my increase is not negotiable because it has been handed down to my boss from central HR 5-6 layers of management away.
This has to be a common issue; and the solution is not to simply change companies.
- toomuchtodo 8y ago> How do you negotiate for a pay increase when the pay increase is controlled centrally? Unions (organize) [1]. Politics (labor regulations) [2]. If you're on a shorter timeline, and regulatory capture isn't in effect, leave with some of your coworkers and cannibalize some of your employer's business. Last option is to simply suffer in silence. That option sucks, don't take it. (Note: If you're reading HN, this most likely doesn't apply to you. You're a privileged tech worker not facing the same perils of most of the US workforce. You're not my audience. Engage your fellow citizen and learn some empathy and compassion.) [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/08/union-inequality-wages/497954/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/08/union-i... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_socialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_socialism
- robertk 8y agoWrite a letter to the members of the Board of Directors, or complain to a federal or state employment or business agency.
- killjoywashere 8y agoTell them you have multiple offers elsewhere. I am that boss. Amazingly, HR discovered they have a "retention incentive" avsilable. To help me keep my employee.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIf your boss really wants to give you a raise very often he can if he actually tries. Unfortunately companies have become really good at hiding behind their policies as long as it's convenient.
- alain94040 8y agoYou misunderstand the fundamental reason why you are getting a 2% salary increase every year. Because when you joined the company, 5 years ago, you were happy with $XX,000. You were ok with that salary one year ago. What changed? Why would you suddenly want a lot more? PS: the answer is "because the market has moved and values me at that higher price now", which needs to be backed up with something such as a job offer (dangerous), or better, evidence (my friends with similar resumes are getting offers at that price).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AstralStorm 8y agoThe evidence gets you nothing. Only an actual job offer could work, anything else is unsafe in the extreme and might get you big unwanted notice. Trying to negotiate from weak no fallback position is bad. (In other words, it can get you shortlisted and potentially flagged as a troublemaker. Say bye to references. Employers talk sometimes.)
- BurningFrog 8y agoThe best way is unfortunately to find a better offer from an other employer. Then you either take that offer or get a decent counteroffer from your current place. It's a lot of work and inconvenience, which is one reason it actually works.
- kmkemp 8y agoIt's very common. Everyone realizes at some point in their career the simple, obvious truth: companies want to pay as little as they can to retain talent, which is obviously opposed to the employee's interest. They also don't want employees to have a hostile relationship with their manager, so they implement policies that seemingly remove their manager's wishes from the equation. Of course, that isn't true. The second that you walk in the door with a better offer, money will magically become available. Everything is negotiable.
- Gustomaximus 8y ago> The second that you walk in the door with a better offer, money will magically become available. Everything is negotiable. This is only for a fairly limited amount of jobs. As a side point I've seen if people have an 'alternate offer' that gets over bid to stay, they'll probably be gone in 6 months anyway so unless there is a specific short-term reason to hold someone I'd not encourage this, but hope companies give generous pay rises as default to underpaid value producing employees. People looking to leave may cite money but there are normally greater reasons the start this path.
- halbritt 8y agoFirst and foremost, learn how to negotiate. Read the book, "Never Split the Difference". Secondly, start looking for another job. Once you have an offer in hand that you'd be willing to accept, you'll be in a better place to negotiate a raise.
- PopeDotNinja 8y agoTL;DR -- A company's compensation strategy is often not optimized for retaining the best employees. As I understand it, in any organization with formalized job classifications, each job classification has a compensation range attached to it. To keep things simple, let's say that each position has a fixed salary attached to it, and that salary is automatically adjusted upwards to match increases in the cost of living. So if you're a Software Engineer 1 (SE-1), and you want to get a raise, you need to become a Software Engineer 2 or higher (SE-2+). So how do you go from an SE-1 to SE-2+? Figure that out, and you'll have figured out a path to predictably negotiating a higher salary. If you find yourself in a position where the company will is actively help you advance your career, consider yourself fortunate :) . It's not uncommon to work for an employer who doesn't help much with career advancement, and it's often easier to get a pay bump by moving to another company.