3 ms·
As it should remain! The fundamental problem is this concept of "identity" is a bundled abstraction that is being used in order to ignore every way in which sc
by mindslight 8y ago
As it should remain!
The fundamental problem is this concept of "identity" is a bundled abstraction that is being used in order to ignore every way in which scaling to the Internet is intrinsically difficult. Because sitting down face-to-face with someone yesteryear was completely and totally safe, so if only we can replicate that and "know" the other person, then all of these newfangled problems will just disappear!
This is a partial list of actual problems "identity" is purporting to solve and an example of someone heavily relying on it: user-device security (Coinbase), cross-medium access (banks), Sybil problem (Google / IRS), persistent tracking (commercial surveillance), offline transactions (healthcare industry).
Each one of these is an area of research unto itself, but yet "identity" is going to solve all of them together! Really, it is just a crutch that allows organizations to pretend to have solved the issues, and then act entitled when their "solution" falls apart. After having architected their systems as if their identifiers are entirely reliable, any action purporting to have been done by you is then your mess to clean up! Because "your" identity was "stolen", see? Problem solved!
This article ultimately seems like a submarine for the industry consortium of the week. The primary reason a "good" identity system hasn't taken off is that the main thing demanded by users is to create arbitrary unlinkable nyms. Meanwhile these backwards-thinking organizations are looking to "identity" mainly to prevent people from doing just that!
- closeparen 8y agoThe main thing demanded by users is cheap credit, which is diametrically opposed to a system designed to optimize the ease of fraud, as you suggest. Use all the scare quotes you want. You are one person, not several, and are accountable for your actions regardless of which pseudonym you wish to present them under.
- mindslight 8y agoOnly two of the five aspects I listed involve credit. And I'm pretty sure at this point people would be much happier getting healthcare without implicit credit, and thus not end up receiving kilodollar nastygrams in the mail for months afterwards. There are plenty of contexts for which there is nothing to be "accountable" for - I would say most general Internet use. And sure, it's possible to disagree reasonably about this, perhaps asserting that you only want to read comments that are policed by some authority. But it is an explicit tradeoff, not merely implicit that we should live in a world without some absolute privacy. There are plenty of current reliances on "identity" that don't pass the smell test - for example the seemingly common flow of setting up online banking by going home, going to a website, and entering in your public identifiers. In the context of a brick and mortar bank, this is utterly backwards! Describing an identity system based on nyms as having been "designed to optimize the ease of fraud" is utterly disingenuous. Fraud requires the other party to buy in to assumptions which are then invalidated. Most uses of identity, say online user accounts, don't need to carry such strong assertions in the first place. Also, highlighting that a term carries a loaded defintion is not using "scare quotes".