5 ms·
Some animals can be kept in captivity well. Dolphins no, but tigers, bears, zebra and the like can do very well. Work with animals in the wild. Learn the mis
by sandworm101 8y ago
Some animals can be kept in captivity well. Dolphins no, but tigers, bears, zebra and the like can do very well. Work with animals in the wild. Learn the misery that is thier "natural" life before making some high-minded judgement about fences. See how many ticks live on a wild lion's face, what starvation means. Zoos are hard, very expensive, but can be ethical. They can give some animals a good life and by doing so fill a social purpose.
Be afraid of a world without zoos. Look at what happens to people who never see animals. Talk to anyone who grew up without dogs. They have all sorts of misconceptions. Zoo animals represent the wild. They manifest our nebulous ideas about wildlife and wild spaces. Without them our kids will too easily dismiss wild nature. To demonstate to kids that wild animals have the right to exist we need to first show them how they actually exist. Nothing does that so well as seeing the wild in the flesh.
- Robotbeat 8y agoDunno why you were downvoted. This is a legitimate position, even if you might disagree.
- cabaalis 8y ago> This is a legitimate position, even if you might disagree. The downvotes are because in 2018, people believe the only legitimate positions are ones in which they agree. The others must become greytext, since they might convince other people.
- sandworm101 8y agoBecause it is cool to hate on zoos. Zoo attendance is down. Schools are afraid to take kids to even the best and most ethical zoos, but look at all the zoo-based tv shows. We want to see and learn about the animals. We just dont want to be seen seeing then. The thought of kids only seeing sharks in a VR helmets is more politically acceptable these days. That future fills me with dread. Too many people hate sharks already. Lol, the votes on my previous post are bouncing between -3 and +2 every minute. It is more devisive than trump's twitter feed.
- guildenstern 8y agoExcept we have zoos now and we treat animals very poorly, consider the billions upon billions of animals we slaughter every single year who’ve been forced to live in torturous conditions — zoos haven’t saved them. Perhaps zoos aren’t the solution, maybe if we stopped the wholesale destruction of animals in our every day lives that compassion would spread to wild animals and we wouldn’t need zoos to remind people that animals aren’t just tools for us to abuse.
- eganist 8y ago> Except we have zoos now and we treat animals very poorly, consider the billions upon billions of animals we slaughter every single year who’ve been forced to live in torturous conditions — zoos haven’t saved them. There's a false equivalence here. Zoos--and other tools like them which grant exposure--bring awareness to a challenge or a problem. Without them, awareness would be fleeting if not entirely absent from the western world as a direct consequence of the fact that far too many species housed in zoos just do not exist in the same regions of the world as developed economies right now. In other word, zoos beget awareness, which drive people like yourself to protect and care for the many forms of life with which we share this planet. I suspect there would be a much harder time convincing people in the developed world to pay e.g. Africa or the Pacific Islands a visit without an initial exposure to their simulated wilds in a well-maintained zoo.
- guildenstern 8y agoZoos have nothing to do with my beliefs around animal welfare and that assumption shows your blinkered view of this problem. The fundamental problem is that humans view animals as tools, torture and murder for our benefit is normalised from birth and zoos are just an extension of that. You can argue that zoos play a part in giving some humans some compassion towards some animals but what use is that when their next stop after the lion enclosure is the hotdog cart. We shouldn’t need zoos. There’s lots of non-invasive ways to learn about animals, and if our shared fundamental belief was that we should do everything we can to show animals compassion and respect, then at no point would anyone need to say “unless these kids see a caged tiger they’re not going to consider the consequences of deforestation”.
- formula1 8y agoImportant to keep in mind, while tigers may have statistics showing a better life than in the wild, reproduction in the zoo has been a problem. There is still more thay can be done but I agree that there is valid arguments for zoos
- Someone1234 8y ago> while tigers may have statistics showing a better life than in the wild And who paid for those statistics and what measures did they use? I'd love to know how you quantify a tiger's happiness.
- formula1 8y agoSickness, risk reward regarding prey, accidents and poachers will probably not be taken care of by vets Granted, peta and humane society have exposed some zoos mistreat many animals which may swing the statistics in favor of the wild. Nonetheless, we have laws and those laws are meant to protect the animals even if they dont succeed 100% atm
- Someone1234 8y agoYou're arguing that a lion that sits in such a small cage it cannot run, has nothing to hunt, and little to do, is better off because they might get ticks out in the wild? Really? And if you want to talk about starvation, then let's talk about the source of Lions struggling out in the world, like human encroachment on their hunting grounds, farming, deforestation, etc. A theoretical zoo paradise could work, but such a zoo would look more like a wildlife refuge than what we're typically used it. And members of the public may even have to put up with wild predators actually killed their food, and not seeing some of the wildlife very often. Most zoos have small enclosures for economic reasons, not because it is what the animals themselves need.
- marcoperaza 8y ago>You're arguing that a lion that sits in such a small cage it cannot run, has nothing to hunt, and little to do, is better off because they might get ticks out in the wild? Really? And if you want to talk about starvation, then let's talk about the source of Lions struggling out in the world, like human encroachment on their hunting grounds, farming, deforestation, etc. Do you know what happens to male lions in the wild? A stronger male lion takes their mate, kills their children, and then kills them. And this is just the ones lucky enough to survive that long. Male lions are kicked out of their pride as soon as they reach adolescence. Most don’t even make it to adulthood or survive long enough to mate. And if you’ve never seen an animal kill another animal, they don’t exactly prioritize a quick and painless death. Life as a wild lion is nasty, brutish, and short. It’s incredible, the the romantic notions that people dream up for themselves.
- tdb7893 8y agoFirstly I think characterizing the natural state of animals as "misery" is very misleading and using that to justify caging them seems strange. Also, I don't think that zoos are inherently unethical but they need to always be cognizant of maximizing the animals welfare, which is what the zoos talked about in the article are doing.
- chongli 8y agoI don't know how else to describe it when I see a starving bear with mange, infested with parasites. Misery sounds like the most appropriate word for it. It's not controversial around here to say that humans are having an enormous impact on the natural environment. The distinction between 'zoo' and 'wild' is not a binary one; humans effects are seen in both. Lots of people have this romantic image of the wild as this pristine place where everything lives in beautiful harmony. In reality it's much more like the Hunger Games than we'd care to admit.
- tdb7893 8y agoThe fact is that most animals in the wild simply aren't doing as terribly as you imply. My wife researches dog welfare and my understanding (which by the way is still not very good at all) is that most emotions don't map perfectly from human to animals so the best thing to look at would be chronic stress response and while animals in the wild are more stressed out (and there's a valid argument to be made that many species are actually happier in captivity) to characterize the levels of most wild animals as "misery" simply isn't true.
- sandworm101 8y agoMost of them aren't currently doing all that bad. But some of them are and most of them eventually will be miserable in the future. Point at a random lion or wolf in the wild and they are happy, loaded with itchy parasites, but fine. Eventually they will all either get sick or be injured. Prey animals die quickly, ripped apart by the lions and wolves. Top predators are doomed to suffer. Their final days, weeks, sometimes years of suffering with a debilitating injury are not pleasant. That misery is what a good zoo removes as compensation for captivity. It is the least we can do. Whether that exchange is fair is a judgement call, but when making it we must remember that our ideals of nature and natural existence are not necessarily universal. Many a wolf might gladly live inside a fence in exchange for never being hungry, cold or itchy again.
- chriskanan 8y agoMany animals seem to have poor mental health in zoos, and bears, gorillas, penguins, tigers, and others are given anti-depressants and/or anti-anxiety drugs [0-4]. Repetitive behaviors, e.g., the back and forth pacing behavior of carnivores or swimming continually in a circle, is supposedly a sign of psychosis caused by confinement. An environment free from danger without the threat of hunger seems to lead to mental health problems in these animals. That said, I think zoos are critical to educating the public about animals, preserving endangered species, enabling injured animals to live, and making people care about animals from an early age. [0] https://www.wired.com/2014/07/animal-madness-laurel-braitman/ https://www.wired.com/2014/07/animal-madness-laurel-braitman... [1] https://www.peta.org.uk/blog/why-are-these-penguins-taking-antidepressants/ https://www.peta.org.uk/blog/why-are-these-penguins-taking-a... [2] http://www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/why-do-polar-bears-need-prozac/ http://www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/why-do-polar-... [3] http://www.toledoblade.com/frontpage/2005/09/12/Zoos-using-drugs-to-help-manage-anxious-animals.html http://www.toledoblade.com/frontpage/2005/09/12/Zoos-using-d... [4] http://www.slate.com/blogs/wild_things/2014/06/20/animal_madness_zoochosis_stereotypic_behavior_and_problems_with_zoos.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/wild_things/2014/06/20/animal_mad...
- coldtea 8y ago>Some animals can be kept in captivity well. Dolphins no, but tigers, bears, zebra and the like can do very well. Very well in what regard? Live many years? Slaves can live many years too if you don't abuse them too much. >Work with animals in the wild. Learn the misery that is thier "natural" life before making some high-minded judgement about fences. Misery for who? For the tiger, or for those judging that they must be miserable because they have ...ticks or hadn't had a deer in a few days?