4 ms·
I read so many stories about companies with new ideas for satellite internet. But i am visiting my parents next weekend. Their house is off grid in rural BC.
by sandworm101 8y ago
I read so many stories about companies with new ideas for satellite internet. But i am visiting my parents next weekend. Their house is off grid in rural BC. They only have one internet option: a dish pointed to a geostationary sat which I will no doubt have to repoint on saturday. They pay insane rates for practically no bandwidth. There is only the one company: explorenet. When exactly are any of these innovations going to hit the canadian market?
- awake 8y agoCheckout starlink the satellite network being created by spacex. Here is a good FAQ https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/comments/7zqm2c/starlink_faq/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/comments/7zqm2c/starlink_f...
- sandworm101 8y agoGreat, but while i see lots of talk of this for ships and planes i've seen not a single file or application from spacex to become a residential provider anywhere, much less in canada. So they remain perpetually 10+ years away.
- gammatrigono 8y agohttps://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-authorizes-spacex-provide-broadband-satellite-services https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-authorizes-spacex-provide-b... Residential service filing probably (!) appears on the priority list after launching the 4-12,000 satellites into LEO.
- walrus01 8y agoIt is much more likely that it will be economical to use in a similar method to o3b, to bring a decent amount of capacity to a single location (example: totally isolated very rural valley somewhere in northern BC), and then distribute bandwidth from there. The link budget problems for gain and EIRP, and cost of CPE, may make it cost prohibitive to put individual CPEs on peoples' roofs as a competitor to last mile WISPs. I can see a scenario where a WISP buys a $7000 to $15000 dual-antenna terminal and a monthly recurring service package in the $700 to $1200/mo range, for a decent chunk of semi-dedicated capacity, and then redistributes access from there. For those who want to understand how this works, o3b at MEO works on the same general concept, but at a more expensive and high bandwidth scale. It's been operational for years now. There's lots of good reference material out there on O3B. Take the same two-satellite make-before-break handoff system used by o3b and apply it to a much larger number of LEO satellites, and smaller terminals, that's the general idea of how oneweb and starlink are intended to work.
- goodcanadian 8y agoWhen exactly are any of these innovations going to hit the canadian market? When are they going to hit any market? There are plenty of companies promising the world, but it is a difficult, expensive, and time consuming problem. I believe better options will come, but I don't see any on the near term horizon.
- walrus01 8y agoWithout asking too much detail, approximately where is there house? Is there any chance there is a regional WISP they could get service from? In general, consumer grade VSAT service via geostationary satellite should be a last resort, if anything else is available. The economics of launching 5000 kilogram satellites into geostationary orbits mean that transponder kHz in Ku/Ka-band spot beams need to be significantly oversubscribed. The actual cost of satellite capacity, translating dedicated (1:1 ratio) Mbps into transponder capacity, plus the cost of running earth stations on the ISP uplink side, can range from $1800 to $5500 per Mbps per month. In order to make any money at all off a large number of $100 to $150/month consumer grade VSAT services it needs to be radically oversubscribed. Xplornet has a particularly bad reputation as an ISP in general, which doesn't help. Things like SpaceX's starlink or other upcoming LEO/MEO services like Oneweb are promising. But not available yet. Point to multipoint wireless last mile via 2.4/3.5/3.65/5.2/5.8 GHz bands can be much more effective. It's even possible for WISPs to offer 75 Mbps x 25 Mbps packages based off the latest Ubiquiti 802.11ac gen2 platforms, Cambium PMP450 or Mimosa A5 AP radio platforms. Disclaimer: I work in both satellite Internet and point-to-point/point-to-multipoint microwave and millimeter wave.
- sandworm101 8y agoEgmont BC. Only 80km (50 miles) from Vancouver. Not exactly remote by Canada or even British Columbia standards. It is also only 79km from Whistler, but look at what stands between Egmont and whistler to get an idea BC terrain. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Egmont,+BC+V0N+2H4/@49.750013,-123.9420878,2895m/data=!3m2!1e3!4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x5487bcfa588ed2b5:0x89adce6265349b19!8m2!3d49.75!4d-123.933333 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Egmont,+BC+V0N+2H4/@49.750... I've looked into every option. The irony is that the nearest cell tower is just over a kilometer away. The problem is the rocky terrain and dense pacific coastal rain forest. Trees heavy with water droplets suck up everything, from sound to radio. It is shocking how a heavy mist dulls everyone's cellphone boosters. Voice calls only last a second or two even on dry days. Everyone uses text messaging. There have been many multipoint proposals. The problem is the rugged coast. Even a 1000' tower wouldn't have line of sight to every house. It would take all sorts of relays atop individual hills. And those relays need power, which is tricky. Buried lines aren't an option (rock) and towers are expensive (forest).
- snowwindwaves 8y agoWe get satellite internet from Infosat also in BC. It's not cheap either though.
- sandworm101 8y agoDifferent company, same sats iirc.
- thebigspacefuck 8y agoLooks like you can get 25 Mbps with a 300GB cap for $120. That's not bad IMO. I'm paying $40/month for 25Mbps but I also live in the city so other things are more expensive.