5 ms·
I know that some people claim we could but it is often because they do not look at every angle, especially economics, and scalability. Global scale endeavors te
by ekianjo 8y ago
I know that some people claim we could but it is often because they do not look at every angle, especially economics, and scalability. Global scale endeavors tend to be complex and require long timelines.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThere is a known straight-forward way to solve the economic problem. You impose a large carbon tax per ton of CO2 and use 100% of the money to subsidize power generation from non-fossil energy sources per KWh. Schedule regular increases in the rate over time, announced years in advance. There are only two real impediments to this happening. The first is lobbying from oil and coal companies (especially in the United States). The only solution for it is to have the will to tell them off and do it anyway. The second is that nobody wants to do it alone. Having a carbon tax is a relative disadvantage -- if everybody does it then everybody is in the same boat, but if only you do it then everyone else is going to out-compete you, so you need some coordination method. In particular, what keeps happening is that Europe and China are willing to reduce emissions but not if the United States won't and the United States has a large oil industry that it doesn't want to see destroyed even though that's what needs to happen. The answer is for the other countries to be serious about it and not take no for an answer -- literally stop trading with countries that won't do it. Give the US the choice between the oil industry and literally every other industry and the choice is easy. That doesn't work for everyone. It isn't going to get a random African dictatorship to reduce its emissions. But none of the countries it wouldn't work on are major carbon emitters to begin with. The problem is that nobody is willing to put their foot down.
- listenallyall 8y ago> lobbying from oil and coal companies (especially in the United States) Ooooh, blame those evil, all-powerful, unstoppable, puppet-master "lobbyists." How about reality: China uses 4x the coal as the USA. https://www.theatlas.com/charts/Nya6gW4s https://www.theatlas.com/charts/Nya6gW4s
- wk_end 8y agoChina’s well more than 4x the population of the US. Those stats, from 2012, are quite outdated, too; while still the largest users of coal (but again, largest country) they’re rapidly and aggressively investing in green energy and cutting back on coal use. The Chinese produce much less carbon per capita than Americans do [1] and recently hit their carbon reduction targets well ahead of schedule [2]. [1] https://www.ucsusa.org/global-warming/science-and-impacts/science/each-countrys-share-of-co2.html https://www.ucsusa.org/global-warming/science-and-impacts/sc... [2] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-climatechange-carbon/china-meets-2020-carbon-target-ahead-of-schedule-xinhua-idUSKBN1H312U https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-climatechange-carbo...
- listenallyall 8y agoGreat for China! The point is that the OP used the all-too-common, purposefully-vague "lobbyist" argument into his rant, as if a profession (rather than the oil and gas companies for whom they work) is responsible for all the global warming problems in the world. Further, the OP obscures the simple fact that even with large shifts in power production over the next few decades, China is, and will remain, the largest coal consumer in the world by far. And yet his suggestion is to cut off the USA, not China, from all global trading.
- wk_end 8y agoThe oil and gas companies employ lobbyists as a means to effect policy changes (or inaction), so...well, despite your snippy attempt to clarify I'm still not sure exactly what your point here is? Yes, the oil and gas companies are the bad guys, I doubt anyone (myself or OP included) would disagree; the problem is that the tens of millions of dollars each year they spend lobbying is apparently a very effective weapon (that they probably shouldn't have) to prevent collective climate action. And yes, the proper global action is to punish climate hogs like the US. And to be clear, once again, relatively speaking China's not a climate hog: it's inane to demand a country of 1.5 billion reduce its total coal usage to less than that of a country less than a quarter of the size before demanding the smaller country to do anything at all, and even more inane to try to punish countries who are aggressively working towards a solution (Europe, China), instead of those actively fighting against one (the US). From some kind of top-down perspective, where you have total control over all aspects of policy in all countries, then yes, I suppose the focus should be on China. But that's not the way the global economy works; it's a game where no one country will be gladly willing to sacrifice its competitive advantage, and that's why per capita figures matter more than raw numbers.
- intended 8y agoThis is incorrect - the fact is that we cannot afford it at all A carbon tax of that nature will kill global growth, and our ability to service debt. A carbon tax will mean many businesses will shut down or have their margins pruned significantly - costs which will be pushed to consumers. This means lower global growth rates, which is not something politicians can sell, especially since the source of funds (corporations) will fund politicians who oppose it. So it’s not just that nobody is willing to put their foot down, it’s that no one can afford to, without suffering huge repercussions.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> A carbon tax of that nature will kill global growth, and our ability to service debt. Any discussion of growth and cost has to be industry-specific. Obviously a carbon tax is bad for the oil industry and good for the solar industry -- that's the whole point. But you're assuming it would be bad for everyone else, which isn't actually true. Consider what happens when you have a cross-subsidy like that. The oil and coal companies have a bunch of known reserves and existing infrastructure -- already explored, already built. When the new policy arrives, suddenly the cost of solar or wind goes from e.g. $.06/KWh to $.04/KWh, meanwhile the total cost of oil or coal-fired power generation goes from $.04/KWh to $.06/KWh -- at the previous market commodity prices. But nobody is going to pay $.06/KWh for oil or coal when they can get solar or wind for $.04/KWh, so if the fossil fuel industry wants to make any use of their existing reserves and existing infrastructure, they have to eat the entire difference out of their profits -- they have to charge $.04/KWh after-tax in order to continue to compete in the market. So the first question is, should we feel sorry for them? No. If you built a coal-fired power plant in 1945 then you've more than recovered your investment already. If you built or acquired one in 2010, decades after we've known this was a problem, you get what you deserve. So the initial effect is a transfer of profits from the fossil fuel industry to the non-fossil fuel energy industry, but no actual change in the price of electricity -- after all, it's revenue neutral. The government isn't keeping any of the money. What happens next is that oil exploration ceases to exist. There is no point in searching for more oil if the pre-tax market price is $10/barrel; it's not profitable. They'll sell the reserves they have for whatever they can get because what else are they going to do with them, but then they're done -- that's the whole idea. Meanwhile there is a huge boom in renewables because all the profits are there now -- all the profits the oil producers would have had are going to install solar panels instead. So what does that make energy costs look like in ten or twenty years? Well, the two effects mostly cancel out. The existing oil and coal reserves get used up and not replaced, but in the meantime we're building non-fossil alternatives to replace them, using the money we're not paying to the oil producers. It's likely that the price would be slightly higher, because otherwise it's what the market would have done without the tax (though that is actually already happening somewhat because the prices are already pretty close), but the net result isn't a huge price differential because they're countervailing forces. The major effect is what happens to the people who own the existing oil reserves. But notice that these are predominantly countries we don't really love, like Russia and Saudi Arabia. So the main effect is to transfer wealth from those countries to the local economy where you create jobs installing renewable energy infrastructure, which is an effect that significantly outweighs -- is net economically positive -- against a slight increase in generating costs, for any country that is not a large net oil exporter. And that's assuming an increase in demand for renewables doesn't bring any economies of scale that could bring the price down below the existing energy market price.
- greglindahl 8y agoOne thing that I do know is that wind and solar have more installations and lower cost than every projection. So they're projected to not be enough... eh?
- jabl 8y agoIndeed. It's awesome that they are beating projections, but even so, the rate is far below what is needed to decarbonize the energy sector by mid-century which is what we need to keep warming below 2C.
- greglindahl 8y agoIt is? That's because we aren't spending very much on wind+solar, because the projections said that the wind+solar industry couldn't grow fast enough. It's all circular reasoning. Me, I'm for spending more on what's working.