4 ms·
> I feel it should include mortgage interest, excluding principal. It does. When you start a mortgage, interest is around 90% of the payment. So by definition
by ars 8y ago
> I feel it should include mortgage interest, excluding principal.
It does. When you start a mortgage, interest is around 90% of the payment. So by definition mortgage is virtually all interest.
True, later the amount of interest goes down, but that's just a detail - the amount of money tied up in the house is what matters, not the accounting in your bank.
- perl4ever 8y agoIf 90% of your rent is interest, why can't someone who's paid off their mortgage rent to you for 90% less?
- jurassic 8y agoMaybe they could, but why would they? Landlords charge rent according to what the market will pay, not what their costs are.
- ianai 8y agoThey would if there was someone else in the market selling closer to cost. But real estate isn’t an efficient market.
- perl4ever 8y agoThat's my argument though - if someone is charging 90% less, why would anyone pay more just because someone else has more expenses.
- loco5niner 8y agoBecause of opportunity cost. They've now invested their efforts and money into a house, and are now reaping the benefits of their investment. They could invest it elsewhere, and charging a renter less money "because charity", doesn't make a lot of sense.
- perl4ever 8y agoYou're not looking at the other side of the coin. Why would a renter pay ten times as much "because charity"? Nobody who has to compete with others gets to set a price based on their costs.
- loco5niner 8y ago> Nobody who has to compete with others gets to set a price based on their costs. Sure they can. They can set whatever price they want. And on the other side of the coin, the available pool of renters can choose to pay that price or not pay that price.
- loco5niner 8y ago> if someone is charging 90% less No one is going to charge 90% less than they are able to (except in charity cases). It goes against human nature.
- aidenn0 8y agobecause they could sell the house and invest the money in stocks and bonds and make more than renting to you at the discount.
- ars 8y agoSummary: That principal is the main profit of the landlord. The time spent building up that principal is not a large moneymaker, since all your income goes to interest. Read on "opportunity cost of money". They could rent that way, and some people do: People who just want things simple and don't care that much about getting the most money. If you are a renter your goal is to try make this happen, by being so easy for your landlord that he's willing to do this for you (it usually ends up as him never raising the rent, over time this reduces your cost because of inflation). Things like never calling him with problems, always paying the rent on time without being reminded, stuff like that. (Doesn't always work of course, it depends on your landlord.) But anyway, normally people try to maximize the value of their money. So they'll take that money locked up in principal and go buy another house and rent that out. Each time they pay off enough of their mortgage they'll go buy something else. Over time you'll have a large fleet of houses, and a nice income. Or, you can take that principal and invest in anything else. Or even just live off of it (it's your profit after all). That's the simple, boring, way to make money in real estate. You basically multiply your money each time you buy another house. You start young, and don't make much. By the time you are older you have a steady income.
- loco5niner 8y agoNo one is going to rent you a place for $100 when they could rent it to you for $1000 (unless it's your mom).