6 ms·
Can zoos be redesigned for a more ethical generation?
- devoply 8y agoWhy don't we pay humans to act like certain animals in zoos?
- williamdclt 8y agoWhat is your point?
- blackoil 8y agoCheck out the reality shows. May not be accurate representation of humans or worse maybe it is.
- WilliamEdward 8y agoWhy? You can watch people in captivity working their dead-end jobs for free.
- sandworm101 8y agoSome animals can be kept in captivity well. Dolphins no, but tigers, bears, zebra and the like can do very well. Work with animals in the wild. Learn the misery that is thier "natural" life before making some high-minded judgement about fences. See how many ticks live on a wild lion's face, what starvation means. Zoos are hard, very expensive, but can be ethical. They can give some animals a good life and by doing so fill a social purpose. Be afraid of a world without zoos. Look at what happens to people who never see animals. Talk to anyone who grew up without dogs. They have all sorts of misconceptions. Zoo animals represent the wild. They manifest our nebulous ideas about wildlife and wild spaces. Without them our kids will too easily dismiss wild nature. To demonstate to kids that wild animals have the right to exist we need to first show them how they actually exist. Nothing does that so well as seeing the wild in the flesh.
- Robotbeat 8y agoDunno why you were downvoted. This is a legitimate position, even if you might disagree.
- cabaalis 8y ago> This is a legitimate position, even if you might disagree. The downvotes are because in 2018, people believe the only legitimate positions are ones in which they agree. The others must become greytext, since they might convince other people.
- sandworm101 8y agoBecause it is cool to hate on zoos. Zoo attendance is down. Schools are afraid to take kids to even the best and most ethical zoos, but look at all the zoo-based tv shows. We want to see and learn about the animals. We just dont want to be seen seeing then. The thought of kids only seeing sharks in a VR helmets is more politically acceptable these days. That future fills me with dread. Too many people hate sharks already. Lol, the votes on my previous post are bouncing between -3 and +2 every minute. It is more devisive than trump's twitter feed.
- guildenstern 8y agoExcept we have zoos now and we treat animals very poorly, consider the billions upon billions of animals we slaughter every single year who’ve been forced to live in torturous conditions — zoos haven’t saved them. Perhaps zoos aren’t the solution, maybe if we stopped the wholesale destruction of animals in our every day lives that compassion would spread to wild animals and we wouldn’t need zoos to remind people that animals aren’t just tools for us to abuse.
- eganist 8y ago> Except we have zoos now and we treat animals very poorly, consider the billions upon billions of animals we slaughter every single year who’ve been forced to live in torturous conditions — zoos haven’t saved them. There's a false equivalence here. Zoos--and other tools like them which grant exposure--bring awareness to a challenge or a problem. Without them, awareness would be fleeting if not entirely absent from the western world as a direct consequence of the fact that far too many species housed in zoos just do not exist in the same regions of the world as developed economies right now. In other word, zoos beget awareness, which drive people like yourself to protect and care for the many forms of life with which we share this planet. I suspect there would be a much harder time convincing people in the developed world to pay e.g. Africa or the Pacific Islands a visit without an initial exposure to their simulated wilds in a well-maintained zoo.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoI'm more interested in the story's headline: "Can zoos be redesigned for a more ethical generation?" I'd be interested to hear precisely what the headline's author meant by "more ethical", and his/her reason for believing that the current generation is more ethical.
- cambalache 8y agoCame exactly to make this point.Whig history applied to ethics I guess. Same old navel gazing.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoThanks for introducing the term "Whig history" to me!
- Jagat 8y ago"More ethical generation" "More civilized societies" "Barbarians" "Taming the savages"
- vermooten 8y agoyes, by closing them down and returning the animals to where they belong
- coldtea 8y agoThough we should also heavily protect those places where they belong.
- rblion 8y agoMore natural history museums with stuffed animals that died in captivity, by accident, by natural causes. The kids get to see the animal up close, learn about behavior/history, connect the animal to the 'bigger picture' of the biosphere/ecosystem.
- coldtea 8y agoNo.
- qubax 8y agoCan we just get rid of zoos altogether? Wild animals shouldn't be caged or confined just for our amusement. This goes for all wild animals. I don't think we should be allowed to keep wild animals as pets as it is inhumane. I'd make an exception for research institutions, but with the rise of drone, camera, etc technology, we could and should be studying animals in the wild.
- pmoriarty 8y ago"Wild animals shouldn't be caged or confined just for our amusement." What about for our education? The zoo is the closest a lot of people even come to the natural world and to appreciating and connecting with animals beyond common cats and dogs.