4 ms·
The 'for profit' chart there is the whole story. If your business model is that you can give someone money and then force them to pay it back without any abilit
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
The 'for profit' chart there is the whole story. If your business model is that you can give someone money and then force them to pay it back without any ability to discharge it, you have essentially re-invented indentured servitude. And it attracts scumbags more strongly than a half dead bleeding seal attracts sharks.
We have gone through a couple of very public shutdowns as some of these for profit schools lose their accreditation (and thus their ability to sucker students into student loans). It hurts people who are trying to do the right thing (get an education so that they can improve their job prospects) and it fails to punish the real problem which are people who sell these worthless degrees for over inflated prices.
- wtvanhest 8y agoIt is certainly not the whole story. For profit is a problem, but its a very small problem vs public school debt. You need to multiply the avg by the number of debtors.
- throwawayjava 8y ago8.5% of private non-profit students default, and 13.5% of public non-profit students default. Those are both pretty high numbers, and those are just the defaults; i.e., the worst-case scenario. It's not counting the tens of thousands of people who defer housing, defer saving for retirement, defer saving for their own children's education, or end up on a perpetual treadmill of loan payments that will destroy their ability to retire. We are heading is the worst possible direction wrt regulation of private for-profit institutions; the available data incontrovertibly demonstrates they should be subject to more scrutiny, not less. But that's definitely not the whole story.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI tend to integrate under the curve[1]. Sub prime mortgages didn't tell the whole story either, but what they did was take an at risk population (people who wanted to own a house but didn't have the credit to get a loan) and fix them up with loans they couldn't repay. That doesn't have anything to say about the folks who could qualify for home loans on their own under the stricter rules and could pay them off. That business was fine as well. There are large numbers of for-profit schools who have taken that playbook and replicated it exactly, find people who "want college" but have either not been able to qualify for a state school, and provide a "college product" bundled with a "loan product" knowing that many of those students will never be able to repay the loans. But everyone in the pipeline gets a bit richer in the churn, and the people who take it in the shorts are tax payers and these poor kids who have a bunch of debt and still no way to pay it off. [1] 88 percent of graduates from for-profit colleges had loans (average debt of $39,950) -- https://studentloanhero.com/student-loan-debt-statistics/ https://studentloanhero.com/student-loan-debt-statistics/