4 ms·
Our economy, indeed much of our societal ethos in general, is rooted in the assumption that labor is a scarce commodity. This was true throughout most of human
by lisper 8y ago
Our economy, indeed much of our societal ethos in general, is rooted in the assumption that labor is a scarce commodity. This was true throughout most of human history, but it started becoming less true with the advent of the industrial revolution, and AI and automation will soon drive the last nail in the labor-scarcity coffin.
When labor is scarce, there are two consequences of that scarcity that make our current societal structure work: first, anyone capable of working possesses an inalienable resource (their own labor) that they can exchange for other goods and services in order to survive, and second, basing your economy on this kind of exchange (as opposed to, for example, slave labor) encourages people to work and be productive.
But when labor is no longer scarce, all of this changes in radical ways. Humans in general no longer have access to an inalienable source of wealth, and wealth becomes rooted exclusively in ownership rather than production. We essentially revert back to a slave-like economy, with machines playing the role of chattel slaves. But for non-owners, for people without capital, there is no longer any recourse. Sooner or later, something is going to have to give.
There are only a very few things that humans can still do with more economic effectiveness than machines: drive vehicles, pick fruit, clean houses, and fold shirts. Really, that's about it. And technology is busily chipping away at the first one. Sooner or later, we are going to have to make a fundamental change in how our society is structured, or things will get very unpleasant for a lot of folks.
- skookumchuck 8y ago> Really, that's about it. The roads are clogged every day with people driving to work. Very few of them are driving to a job folding shirts and cleaning houses.
- lisper 8y ago> Very few of them are driving to a job folding shirts and cleaning houses. I think you'd be surprised how many of those people are doing just that. And you left out the third category of work: driving itself. But I did leave out one important category: work requiring interpersonal interactions, like sales, particularly retail sales. But that is starting to go away too.
- wongarsu 8y agoproduct design and development is also a really big category. We have big productivity increases, but so far elastic demand just counters any work speed increase with more demands and design goals, making the sector very stable
- xg15 8y agoYes. People already had that discussion during the original industrial revolution. The one solution that eventually worked were unions. Of course now we're finding ourselves completely surprised at the same point - only that a lot of erosion has already been done to undercut unions.
- zorked 8y agoWas labour ever scarce? Was work ever an inalienable form of wealth? Why did half the world go through communist revolutions, is that because workers were too wealthy?
- lisper 8y ago> Was labour ever scarce? Before the industrial revolution, yes. > Was work ever an inalienable form of wealth? In a society that does not allow slavery, yes.
- MalikOcano 8y agoWas labour ever scarce? Yes after 1/3 to 1/2 of Europe died from the bubonic plague. Workers were scarce so they were able to demand better pay and working conditions. Which is why those who run our economy would prefer to keep labor plentiful.
- SolarNet 8y agoThe labor market has never had the useful properties of free markets we see in other industries. Notably price discovery doesn't function in labor markets because there is no way (for most people) to not participate in the labor market. Non participation is a key property of effective free markets.
- orangecat 8y agoNotably price discovery doesn't function in labor markets because there is no way (for most people) to not participate in the labor market. That doesn't follow, unless you're going to claim that price discovery also doesn't function for food, housing, clothing, and cell phones.
- SolarNet 8y agoFor three out of the four, there are options not to participate. Housing I would claim also suffers from market distortions. Food, I can choose not to participate in any given variety of food markets, I can buy groceries, or I can go to restaurants, or I can buy from family farms and hunters. Or I can make it myself. Clothing is similar to food. And cell phones are trivially easy to refuse to participate.
- visarga 8y ago> But for non-owners, for people without capital, there is no longer any recourse. Sooner or later, something is going to have to give. We still have an inalienable right - to work for ourselves directly, for our family and community. We can be self reliant with the help of human work + judicious use of advanced tech. We revert back to the self reliant farm or village, not to a new age of capital. Self reliant tech such as solar panels, water filtration, computing, AI, 3d-printers, robots and drones would help us achieve that, as long as they are open sourced and a maker culture exists around them. Do you think billions of able, jobless people would prefer to sit around do nothing and collect UBI rather than working to make more out of what they have? What would they do with their free time when they have little resources than to work for themselves and become more self reliant?
- lisper 8y ago> We can be self reliant Really? How? What exactly is someone with no capital assets supposed to do in today's world?
- visarga 8y agoSay you are a jobless teacher. Then you teach poor kids and their parents pay you with food or money. Same for many other non-bullshit jobs - you can work for people who in exchange would render other services or payments back to you. When billions would be jobless, their needs would be ignored by the corporations because there is no profit. But the people would value their needs and work power, and find a way to make due with what they have plus work.
- rohit2412 8y agoIf the AI is a better teacher than you, then the AI will be the teacher, and it takes no salary/food. There will always be jobs that machines can't do. The question is will they be enough for all of humanity? "their needs would be ignored by the corporations because there is no profit." But then how would you pay the teacher? Apparently there was some value in skills and you had money to pay the teacher. Unless you're implying that we'd go back to manually farming the villages, like the amish.
- sabujp 8y ago> There are only a very few things that humans can still do with more economic effectiveness than machines: drive vehicles, pick fruit, clean houses, and fold shirts. Really, that's about it. if by clean house you also mean hvac, plumber, and handyman I'm still waiting for robots to do that because they charge an arm and a leg in large cities
- lisper 8y agoThat's a good point. I should have included construction in the list. [EDIT] On second thought, I've decided that I will not concede construction. My list was supposed to be a post-AI list (though I concede I did not make this sufficiently clear). I think in 20-30 years it's very likely that we'll have robots that can do most construction and repair jobs, if for no other reason that by then most products will be designed to be either robotically repaired or disposable.
- Jtsummers 8y ago> There are only a very few things that humans can still do with more economic effectiveness than machines: drive vehicles, pick fruit, clean houses, and fold shirts. Really, that's about it. And technology is busily chipping away at the first one. Sooner or later, we are going to have to make a fundamental change in how our society is structured, or things will get very unpleasant for a lot of folks. Out of curiosity, have you ever read Vonnegut's Player Piano? It touches on many of these topics, but in particular what you describe is also a key theme. There are few remaining jobs that people can do that machines can't (in the book, tend bar and give a haircut). Human labor is in such a high surplus that the state essentially hires all working age (18-45) males who don't demonstrate the potential to become an engineer or a manager (hews closer to understanding policy, statistics, and systems than actual people management). Then they receive a pension (as in the military today) for the rest of their lives. Societal change becomes necessary, but of course it's Vonnegut so even that doesn't go the way the people intend.
- lisper 8y agoNo, I have not read Player Piano. But I'll put it on my reading list.
- BurningFrog 8y ago> Our economy, indeed much of our societal ethos in general, is rooted in the assumption that labor is a scarce commodity. This was true throughout most of human history, but it started becoming less true with the advent of the industrial revolution This is the exact opposite of historical fact. Before the industrial revolution, labor was next to worthless. Laborers were paid next to nothing by current standards, and lived in poverty below current day third world levels. The industrial revolution made labor more scarce. Many industrial jobs were created and wages rose as competition for workers intensified. This has been going on uninterrupted for 250+ years now. This could change in the future, but note that the impending replacement of human labor by machines have also been predicted for 250+ years. I'll believe it when i see it.
- lisper 8y ago> Laborers were paid next to nothing by current standards, and lived in poverty below current day third world levels. That's true. But... > labor was next to worthless. That does not follow. Before the industrial revolution, nearly everyone, even royalty, lived in what would today be considered poverty. Labor as a percentage of total economic output was much higher before the IR than after. It's just that overall productivity vastly increased. > Many industrial jobs were created and wages rose as competition for workers intensified. That's true, but... > The industrial revolution made labor more scarce. No, that's not true. Yes, many jobs were created, but many previously existing jobs were destroyed. Unemployment as it exists today was unknown before the IR. Please note that I am not saying that these changes are bad. Before the IR, an unemployed person would have been a dead person because there wasn't enough economic margin to support an unproductive population. Unemployment was a luxury that pre-IR society simply could not afford. Society as a whole is vastly better off because of technology. All I'm saying is that the rules we have for how wealth is distributed is based on assumptions that are becoming less and less true as time goes by, and that we need to address this or it will cause more and more serious problems.
- pluto9 8y ago> drive vehicles, pick fruit, clean houses, and fold shirts What? That's a weirdly specific and tiny list. How about: - Nearly any sort of creative work: programming, graphic design, product design, landscaping, architecture, writing marketing copy, technical writing, music. - Diagnosing any complex system. Machines are terrible at diagnosing themselves. Ever pulled an OBD-II code from a car and then wondered which of a hundred actual problems might be the cause of it? How about finding out which exact part is causing your dishwasher to back up and flood? - Actually repairing any problems that have been diagnosed. Repairing a car is vastly more complicated than building one from scratch using a neatly laid out set of parts in a predetermined series of steps. Hell, making a robot that can reliably change lightbulbs in homes would be a milestone achievement. - Construction, or any job that requires using tools to performs a task that isn't defined with absolute precision and sequencing. Similar to repair work. - Human interaction. Medical care, guided tours, live entertainment (not just the performers, but they people they interact with backstage), police work, HR, public relations, management, child care. - Any mission-oriented or long-term goal-oriented work, i.e., military strategy, city planning, legislation, social policy, organizational direction.
- lisper 8y ago> That's a weirdly specific and tiny list. Indeed. I didn't make it sufficiently clear, but I intended this sentence to be the operative one: "AI and automation will soon drive the last nail in the labor-scarcity coffin" So that list was supposed to be a post-AI list, not a contemporary one.