3 ms·
> it's a philosophical one. It is potentially 'falsifiable' by criticism, however Agreed. I think the main issue is not with the idea itself of the scientific
by raverbashing 8y ago
> it's a philosophical one. It is potentially 'falsifiable' by criticism, however
Agreed. I think the main issue is not with the idea itself of the scientific method, rather than the practical implications and its limitations.
- The main idea is a qualitative one. It doesn't consider all the statistical can of worms about reproducibility.
- Real world experiments rarely reproduce perfectly/exactly. The more the experiment involves more variables (or unknown variables) you can detect an effect but its magnitude might vary.
- Not everything can be reproduced, not everything can be measured perfectly, hence the "study of knowledge" needs to be able to handle those cases, and not just bury their head in the sand and go "la la la this is not scientific let's ignore it"
- nonbel 8y agoScientists were reproducing each others work before statistics was a thing. Whatever "statistical can of worms" there is regarding it sounds like a problem with the statistics being used rather than science.
- raverbashing 8y ago> Scientists were reproducing each others work before statistics was a thing They were also doing that before Popper was a thing. > Whatever "statistical can of worms" there is regarding it sounds like a problem with the statistics being used rather than science. Not really. It's easier to prove "Drug X cures dying from disease Y 99% of the time" than "Drug X solves issue Y 30% of the time only in individuals with a certain combination of characteristics".
- nonbel 8y ago> Scientists were reproducing each others work before statistics was a thing They were also doing that before Popper was a thing. Yes, but not sure why you are pointing that out. > Whatever "statistical can of worms" there is regarding it sounds like a problem with the statistics being used rather than science. Not really. It's easier to prove "Drug X cures dying from disease Y 99% of the time" than "Drug X solves issue Y 30% of the time only in individuals with a certain combination of characteristics". If you had a complete understanding you would only apply the drug when it would work and have 100% success rate.
- raverbashing 8y ago> If you had a complete understanding you would only apply the drug when it would work and have 100% success rate. There is no way to have 100% understanding of a specific person to have a designer drug for every condition. Not even Aspirin is 100% effective nor we have a complete understanding of how it works (though there were some discoveries on that regard around 20yrs ago, I think) It's hard for physics and it's impossible for biology (and other fields) to come up with completely accurate predictions.
- nonbel 8y agoDesigning reproducible experiments and making accurate predictions are both important, but they are totally different things. Somehow you've combined them into one concept.
- akvadrako 8y agoAre you really talking about Popper's ideas or just a simplified popular understanding of 'falsifiable'? Popper never said ideas needed to be based on reproducible evidence. He also emphasised explanations over just predictability.
- jhbadger 8y agoWhat would be a case of actual knowledge that isn't scientific and not amenable to falsification though? Even humanities like history use evidence and make conclusions that can be falsified in the light of new information.
- raverbashing 8y agoAnything that is limited in observability. Either because the available sample size is too small, the time or ability to observe something is limited. A bit of a stretch, but I'm also skeptical of the ability of the scientific method to be able to understand/prove anything with (hidden) state/memory. For a lot of 'skeptics' unproven means wrong and unmeasurable means wrong.
- wuzamarine 8y agoFalsifiability violates the Law of Non Contradiction, and Math is the ruling queen of Science.