3 ms·
Again, the more fundamental question being fought over here is who has primacy in the United States, the individual Citizen, or the "collective" Citizens. This
by salawat 8y ago
Again, the more fundamental question being fought over here is who has primacy in the United States, the individual Citizen, or the "collective" Citizens.
This is the primary danger that comes from blind adherence to Democratic/Republican principles. Letting the COLLECTIVE will filter down without bureaucratic checks and balances in terms of having laws expire and having to get reaffirmed as the population changes leads to a slow consolidation of power that goes unchecked to the Federal level.
The Federal Government was not intended to be the hammer that gets thrown about all over the country. The fact that we're even entertaining the discussion that the Federal Government should be able to exercise such primacy in access to personal information is a scary thing indeed.
It was never meant to be that pervasive. This country runs from the bottom up. There are ways for Law Enforcement to do their jobs without ubiquitous capacity to wiretap. The potential for abuse is simply too high.
- forapurpose 8y ago> This country runs from the bottom up. While I very much support individual privacy and liberty, I think the statement above is being misapplied: Yes it runs from the bottom up, and therefore it does not run according to ancient rules and their interpretations. It's a democracy, not a religion; today's voters decide what they want, not ancient prophets (the Founders) who handed down scripture (the Constitution, Federalist Papers, etc.). And in fact, that's how the founders of the U.S. designed it.
- Angostura 8y ago> This country runs from the bottom up. That's all well and good, except irrespective of the issue, if you as an individual Citizen tell Facebook to do something, it will take one look at you and say 'bugger off'. I don't see that there is anything intrinsically wrong with the government directing Facebook to operate within laws or take action. The problem here is that, the particular policy of the government in this case is stupid, and it's up to the collective Citizens to change that policy.
- bilbo0s 8y ago>if you as an individual Citizen tell Facebook to do something, it will take one look at you and say 'bugger off'. This. In my own opinion @salawat's heart is in the right place, but his/her ideas are completely unworkable. Expecting a lone individual in Lincoln, or Birmingham, or Providence, or Dallas to be able to protect his or her rights against Facebook, in the absence of a federal government, is just naive.
- salawat 8y agoThe point I"m making is more along the lines that a slow consolidation of ultimate power at the Federal level is to be avoided. The "Collective" Citizen, represented by the Federal Government, MUST be limited in it's ability to intrude in the affairs of the Individual Citizen. Things like CALEA represent dangerous precedents and potentials for abuse that should require reaffirmation and consistent reevaluation in the light of advancing technology. We all want a powerful and responsible government, but we have to weigh the dangers and potential for abuse in the long run against the short term gains from granting a new power with little or no constraint. Perhaps I didn't express it that well.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]