3 ms·
I'm a happy user. But two things stand out to me as symptomatic of the "we know better than you" aspects. The first is labels. Exposed in IMAP as if Folders but
by ggm 8y ago
I'm a happy user. But two things stand out to me as symptomatic of the "we know better than you" aspects. The first is labels. Exposed in IMAP as if Folders but not folders. Also you can't add more to the steerage bar subtypes of inbox. Also all and spam and unread are magic. This works but gee.. special case? What happened to architecture for generic cases and specialisation afterward?
And then other? ! Keyboard shortcut marks to spam. Even if the current context is the spam label. Why isn't it a toggle? Why can't I unmark spam with the same effective shortcut which contextually makes sense. There is no unspam shortcut, presumably because reasons. (There's a button and generic steerage can get it keyboard only)
Tl;dr he did amazingly good but there are still some moments of whatthefuckery and wheknowbetterthanyou
- rahimnathwani 8y ago"The first is labels. Exposed in IMAP as if Folders but not folders." Are you suggesting that: A) Gmail shouldn't include a label feature? B) Labels shouldn't be exposed via IMAP? C) Something else? I'm hoping it's C (as I like labels, like them being exposed via IMAP, and don't know how else they could have exposed them such that the IMAP clients of the day would have supported them).
- ggm 8y agoI think maybe google should have gone into IMAP standards to explain labels and make them more generally useful. Sieve?
- rahimnathwani 8y agoIn 2010, my primary phone was a Nokia E71. It supported both IMAP and Exchange ActiveSync. IIRC, whichever way was used to access Gmail, labels were usable. If the Gmail team had gone the way you suggest, I'm not sure that phone would ever have been able to access Gmail labels.
- nailer 8y agoPersonally I like C too - gmail should have a real API you can use to make a better client (maybe you want to fix sync between different gmail windows for example, or calendar date autosuggest, which has been broken for years). https://developers.google.com/gmail/api/guides/ https://developers.google.com/gmail/api/guides/ exists but the page states: > Note: The Gmail API should not be used to replace IMAP for full-fledged email client access. Instead, see IMAP and SMTP.