5 ms·
The basis for homophobia being that straight men are scared that gay men might be out to sleep with them has always struck me as odd. Extrapolating from my exp
by jgrahamc 16y ago
The basis for homophobia being that straight men are scared that gay men might be out to sleep with them has always struck me as odd.
Extrapolating from my experience with women (only a tiny minority find me attractive), why would I think that all gay men want to have sex with me?
- cynicalkane 16y agoDon't extrapolate from your experience with women... extrapolate from your experience with men. Men are far less choosy about who they would sleep with, given the opportunity.
- jgrahamc 16y agoReally? Ok, HN... If you are male and would sleep with me please send me email. I'll keep your details secret, but I'd be fascinated to see some hard evidence for this assertion.
- BrandonM 16y agopics or GTFO ;) (I'm straight, and I normally wouldn't say something like this on HN, but it's sooo perfect right here...)
- danilocampos 16y ago> hard evidence for this assertion Regrettable word choice.
- acqq 16y agoThe pictures: http://www.google.com/images?q=John+Graham-Cumming http://www.google.com/images?q=John+Graham-Cumming
- sudont 16y agoEgo?
- mithaler 16y agoThat came across like a straw man to me in the OP, especially in statements like this: > The subtext to a lot of homophobic thinking is the idea that gays will try to get straight people into bed at the first opportunity, or that gays are looking to "convert" straights. Freud called this concept schwanzangst; the U.S. Army calls it Don't Ask Don't Tell. I haven't really heard any arguments from those people that made any sense, but all the same this came across as an uncomfortably large leap.
- gaius 16y agoThe US Army's position is more likely to be "we actually don't care but we can't say that until Congress changes the UCMJ, so, uhh, be all you can be" - that's what don't ask don't tell really means.
- ugh 16y agoMy understanding of DADT is that you cannot be openly gay. Not quite be all you can be.
- gaius 16y agoPerhaps it's a moot point now: http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2010/10/12/us/AP-US-Gays-in-Military.html?_r=1&WT.mc_id=US-SM-E-FB-SM-LIN-JOI-101210-NYT-NA&WT.mc_ev=click http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2010/10/12/us/AP-US-Gays-in-...
- kscaldef 16y agoI'm a little uncertain exactly what part of the quoted text you are objecting to, but there are generally two arguments given for why gays shouldn't be parents, teachers, scoutmasters, etc. a) They will try to convert or otherwise influence children to "turn gay" and, b) they are disproportionately likely to be pedophiles. The arguments for DADT are generally a little different, but there's definitely a thread there that includes the same idea that gays will be unable to resist making sexual advances on their fellow soldiers.
- stavrianos 16y agoThis is not a true rationale- it's a kneejerk reaction. The mention struck me as a joke, not a serious comment. This is already more analysis than the joke deserved.
- RyanMcGreal 16y agoThe fear seems to be more that accepting homosexuality will somehow "normalize" it. I realize that begs the question, but I've never claimed that bigots are logical.
- glhaynes 16y agoSeems like a logical conclusion is that the homophobe is worried that a homosexual will want to sleep with them and that the homophobe will find that situation irresistible. See also: http://ieet.org/index.php/IEET/more/2246 http://ieet.org/index.php/IEET/more/2246 On that note, one should be able to easily Google up studies that have shown correlation between homophobia and being aroused by gay porn...
- sethg 16y agoIf you’re straight, and you’re the sort of man who treats every woman he encounters as little more than a potential sexual conquest, then the thought of another man treating you in that way is a little scary. Reflecting on this emotional reaction, you can either say “gosh, maybe a lot of women get creeped out by the way I treat them, and I should adjust my behavior” or “gosh, I want gay men to be as far away from me as possible”. Alas, many people in this situation take the second option.
- jacoblyles 16y agoNice armchair psychoanalysis, but how does this fit in with the fact that most homophobes are old married folks, not young playboys? The people I know who do things like vote against gay marriage have been married for 20+ years, go to church, and have 3 kids.
- ciupicri 16y agoDo you think that marriage and kids stop someone from flirting and having extra-marital affairs?
- jacoblyles 16y agoDo any of you have any evidence that there is even the smallest correlation between a person having negative views of homosexuality and that person treating women poorly? It's fun to just make up shit about people we disagree with, but it's still dishonest and wrong.
- ciupicri 16y agoWhy are you twisting my words and what did I make up? You said something about the homophobes you know and I added the fact that marriage doesn't stop someone from flirting. This might not make him a playboy, but it's close enough in my opinion. As for cheating, if a man cheats, it doesn't necessarily mean that he's treating women poorly, it means that he's treating a woman poorly.
- garret 16y agoIf I assume women like me, but I'm not getting laid, then I have only myself to blame, and that doesn't feel good. But my pride isn't so attached to the amount of gay sex I'm having.
- eru 16y agoActually straight men should encourage other men to become gay: Less competition.
- helmut_hed 16y agoWell... actually I'm surprised no one has questioned this conclusion from the OP. They say this: "Gay people are not sexually interested in straights" but in fact, what their data indicates is better stated as: "Gay people will not attempt to date people they know to be straight" which is something different.
- btilly 16y agoInterestingly it actually is fairly common for gay men to have a fantasy about converting a straight man to becoming gay. (I learned this tidbit from reading Randy Savage.)
- xpaulbettsx 16y agoIt's the "have sex with an inexperienced virgin" fantasy for gay guys, same underlying idea.
- helmut_hed 16y agoOr the unobtainable person fantasy... btw I hope the parent parent poster means he learned about this from Dan Savage, sex advice columnist, and not Randy "Macho Man" Savage, professional wrestler. Although that stuff is totally homoerotic, so maybe.
- btilly 16y agoOops, you're right. Dan Savage. blush
- jacoblyles 16y ago"Homophobia" is an odd word for "dislike of homosexuality". None of the people that I know with a negative view of homosexuality are afraid that homosexuals will sleep with them. Rather, they think it is wrong/unnatural/icky.