3 ms·
Reminds me of a mostly science fiction concept that would technically help but probably wouldn't be too culturally accepted for varying reasons: creches and pro
by Nasrudith 8y ago
Reminds me of a mostly science fiction concept that would technically help but probably wouldn't be too culturally accepted for varying reasons: creches and professional parent teachers. Essentially extending teaching to the point of having the "unfun" parts taken care of and educational involvement early on while still allowing the biological parents to play the fun uncle/aunt role. With dual career with kids households that already has a predecessor in daycare and babysitters spending more time with their children.
There are some fringe bonuses as well, people who are useful or have other good traits may not be the best for actually raising children. In a hypothetical basic income for most without an unautomatable skill that could produce another job pool.
It has some degree of precedent in the past with the elite having nannys handle most of the childrearing. That also lead to the less bizzare in context Oedipus Complex aspect of Freud. With upper middle class and downward lifestyles the common reaction is "How messed up do you have to be to come up with that conclusion?". But with a combination of genetic sexual attraction and lack of Westermarck effect it makes more sense.
That said while it may work on a technical labor and societal utility level there are many social obstacles and exploitable flaws. One of which is that parents tend to want to be involved with their child(ren)'s li(fe/ves).
Another is control and paying for it - personal attention is needed for best results compared to just enmasse orphanage style. Government provided is exploitable for shaping society in selfish ways. Large corporate providers would suffer from essentially the same issues but slightly different ways of seeking power.
Then there are questions of what sort of control should be allowable vs "the experts" which would be far more contentious than CPS. Private with most control requires income inequality by definition for small "class size" and would fail to provide it enmasse. Plus the competing curve between quality by exclusivity and quality by class size.
And finally there is the human element of emotional bonding, pride in few being willing to admit their child would be best off cared for by others, cultural transmission being valued, and the fact that frankly said positions would be a child molestor's dream beyond typical access to children jobs.