4 ms·
I completely disagree. I grew up as the outsider in the south - liberal ideology, atheist, etc. Through the Clinton, Bush, and Obama eras it was No Big Deal. I'
by komali2 8y ago
I completely disagree. I grew up as the outsider in the south - liberal ideology, atheist, etc. Through the Clinton, Bush, and Obama eras it was No Big Deal. I'd have spats with friends and neighbors, and they'd end friendly. In South Carolina I went from being called the "n-lover whiteboy" to convincing my white friends that my black friends are just as cool, and have good BBQs. We'd all disagree with eachother, but it'd be respectful. Online and off. This is when Facebook/Myspace is just coming out, and "normies" are learning about interacting online, and about how easy it is to forget about the face on the other side of the screen. Even there it wouldn't flare out too horribly.
Something's different, these last few years. Sometime around the tail end of the Obama era is when I began noticing it, that it wasn't a "political disagreement," it was a fundamental inability to reconcile values. It was "freedom of speech vs political correctness," it was "nazis vs antifa," it was "black lives matter vs all lives matter." People getting mass-defriended on facebook, me being mocked by my southern friends for my liberal values (that are the same as they've always been). Things have gotten far more divisive, and if I had to make a guess, I blame the political organizations paying trolls to disseminate divisive fake information across the internet, and prominent politicians engaging in disgusting divisive language (Duterte, Le Pen, Trump, Netanyahu, Erdoğan, ISIS high-production-videos).
- tdb7893 8y agoThe Democrats were still on "don't ask don't tell" in the Clinton era and that policy continued to 2011 so it just seems to me that the rise of this divisiveness came as a natural reaction to Progressives views on race and gender gaining mainstream traction. If you look at how overall society has changed on those issues in the last 20 years the change seems pretty big.
- castlecrasher2 8y agoMaybe you're right. I wonder how much of it is non-stop political articles in our faces if we consume social media combined with the fact that we rely so little on our neighbors and friends because we don't have to so understanding and sympathy skills have plummeted. On the latter point I wonder if lower human social contact and ease of escape online means lower tolerance towards differing opinions, or even things we deem wrong. It feels more and more like typed opinions are people shouting into the sky, and when disagreed with they get offended and lash out or they say "you're not who I was referring to," almost like that racist grandma stereotype.
- komali2 8y agoI'm not sure. I remember having the realization in ~2015 that you aren't allowed to be a moderate, in ANY discussion, on reddit (back when that was the only forum I used regularly). Be the discussion about racism, police brutality, or even whether or not sourdough should be steamed when baked. You are RED or you are BLUE. And if you're BLUE, you're FULL BLUE or you're a nazi. So like I'd come in talking about being a 3rd party voter and get shit on. Or about how there may be middle ground, on, say, gun control, and get downvoted to obvlivion. I don't know, polarization is powerful, I guess. I mean, it seems absurd to me that the 300 million people in this country are literally split black and white down the middle on all issues. Surely not. It defies logic that 150 million all perfectly support total access to guns while also opposing all forms of abortion while also hating all forms of welfare (this definitely can't be possible because shitloads of republican voters are on welfare). So, something's up. My guess is that it behooves those in power to keep the population divided? No idea.
- bufferoverflow 8y ago>"n-lover whiteboy" >... >but it'd be respectful. Does not compute.