5 ms·
How is this different from "influencers" who are required to disclose when they are paid to advertise a product on social media? Amazon should be subject to th
by walterbell 8y ago
How is this different from "influencers" who are required to disclose when they are paid to advertise a product on social media?
Amazon should be subject to the same disclosure requirement, which would negate the value of the tweets, which may remove the need for their employees to be put into this position.
https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2017/04/ftc-staff-reminds-influencers-brands-clearly-disclose https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2017/04/ftc-s...
> The FTC’s Endorsement Guides provide that if there is a “material connection” between an endorser and an advertiser – in other words, a connection that might affect the weight or credibility that consumers give the endorsement – that connection should be clearly and conspicuously disclosed, unless it is already clear from the context of the communication. A material connection could be a business or family relationship, monetary payment, or the gift of a free product. Importantly, the Endorsement Guides apply to both marketers and endorsers ... consumers viewing Instagram posts on mobile devices typically see only the first three lines of a longer post unless they click “more,” which many may not do. The staff’s letters informed recipients that when making endorsements on Instagram, they should disclose any material connection above the “more” button.
- mirimir 8y agoTheir account names begin with "Amazon", so it's pretty obvious, no? @AmazonFCPhil @AmazonFCShaye @AmazonFCLeo
- ErikVandeWater 8y agoCounterpoint: Some people really like Xbox or have followers who like Xbox so they put Xbox in their twitter account name. It does not mean they work for Xbox. @AmazonFCPhil could be looking to connect with other people interested in Amazon. Names on twitter aren't enough to determine where someone works.
- cm2012 8y agoThey also clearly say they work for Amazon in their titles and descriptions.
- coldtea 8y agoHow does that solve the problem? It's Amazon employees tweeting good things about "warehouse working conditions". That gives more legitimacy to their paid for BS for those reading it, not less. ("If the very people who work at Amazon say it's good working conditions, then it must be good")
- cm2012 8y agoThey post facts about working conditions. Quoting someone else: "Tweet: Hello! Amazon does pay their employees minimum wage - any less would be illegal One thing that often gets overlooked are the employee benefits that Amazon provides for all employees - Health insurance, 401K, career/financial counseling. Amazon pays minimum wage is a factual statement. Minimum wage is not a good wage for the job but its still factual. You either offer them health insurance, 401K, counseling or you dont. I would say that's also a factual statement. Whether or not you agree with it is your decision but actually having transparent facts is refreshing these days."
- coldtea 8y ago"Transparent facts" from the "ambassadors"? If only. They can speak of "employee benefits that Amazon provides for all employees" because "all employees" only includes a tiny part of their warehouse workers -- those that are actually employees. The rest? "Technically, Amazon does not hire the workers in its warehouses. Instead, temporary staffing agencies with names like Integrity Staffing Solutions handle the process of interviewing and hiring workers in Amazon's distribution centers. This is a method by which Amazon insulates itself from issues involving unemployment insurance and worker compensation; officially, the temps don't work for Amazon, they work for the temp agency." Among tons of other hellish practices (like micro-measuring their position with GPS trackers, forbidding bathroom breaks, arbitrary raised quotas, demerit points for discipline, and so on...
- walterbell 8y agoShould that be interpreted as Amazon customer service, public relations, marketing, management, warehouse workers, warehouse marketing, warehouse public relations, warehouse management or another department?
- jhall1468 8y agoTheir job titles are on the Twitter accounts and it's "Amazon FC Ambassador". They have the Amazon logo as their profile picture, and their names start with @Amazon. I think we are above and beyond "interpretation" at this point.
- coldtea 8y agoAmazon FC Ambassador means nothing. Most of those glancing at the tweets wont pay attention to the title, just see an overall good message. Many wont know that FC means, or what's an Ambassador in this context (e.g. it could even be like some "employee of the month" thing for fulfillment centers. How about, "Amazon PR executive" or "Amazon shill"? That would make it obvious.
- cm2012 8y agoThat would be just emotional marketing in the other direction (the one you want). Not any more obviously correct.
- coldtea 8y agoOf course more obviously correct, since their warehouses are shitholes for employees -- do some research. It would also be much more accurate as to the reason the Amazon employee writes something positive about the conditions there. Not because they work there, or because they actually believe it is so.
- jhall1468 8y agoDon't be daft. It would take you all of 10 seconds to find out FC is an extremely common acronym for fulfillment center. If you are glancing at tweets and miss the 3 different ways they are advertising that they are Amazon employees I'd call that a "you" problem. Demand transparency, receive it, and demand bias. Really adult way to view the world.
- cm2012 8y agoThey have the words "Amazon FC Ambassador" in their title (shows with every post) and the Amazon logo in their image. That looks a lot like disclosure.
- walterbell 8y agoIs there an industry standard usage of that term that is recognizable by the average social media consumer? E.g. what does "FC" mean? If it were obvious, this story and reaction would not exist.
- cm2012 8y agoFulfillment center. But I think "Amazon Ambassador" makes it clear they are Amazon employees.
- spwmoni 8y agoThere's a difference between an Amazon employee expressing their own opinion and an Amazon employee being explicitly paid to praise their employer, though.
- boron1006 8y ago>If it were obvious, this story and reaction would not exist. You're right, the media would never try and drum up outrage based on spurious facts that can be debunked with 2 minutes of research.
- cm2012 8y agoAs you can see from this thread, people are more than happy to get into an outrage about an article they havn't even read based on their preconceived notions.
- jaredklewis 8y ago> If it were obvious, this story and reaction would not exist. Yea, the press would never knowingly publish an inflammatory article without due cause. How much more obvious can it get than "[Name of the Company] Ambassador"? Sure, "Amazon Shill" would have been more colloquial, but I think it is hard to make the argument that Amazon is hiding that they pay these people. As much as BI is trying to spin this as something they've "uncovered," I think the story is pretty straightforward. When BI asked Amazon about it, they immediately confirmed what was already obvious: that they pay these people.
- siruncledrew 8y agoWhat are the penalties for violating this? I feel like this is something that doesn't get taken seriously, as I see it violated a lot by companies of all sizes using influencers as a marketing/product awareness strategy. Especially with things like sponsored blog posts, Tweets, and Youtube reviews.
- pnathan 8y agothe header image is the amazon logo, in amazon colors. the name is Amazon<foo> I think it passes the clear and conspicuous test.
- coldtea 8y ago>How is this different from "influencers" who are required to disclose when they are paid to advertise a product on social media? It's not, except a social media influencer is not a multi billion dollar company exploiting it workers, they just advertise crap to people. That said, both practices should be banned.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ataturk 8y agoThe once great dreams of the Internet uplifting all mankind and moving us towards some kind of massive sharing on knowledge in order to gain truth has been hijacked by a bunch if idiot fucking shills. It's the same reason these a-holes bought the WaPo.
- drcursor 8y agoHi Walterbell, I want to contact you regarding an old thread here in HN, would you mind reaching out ? https://twitter.com/drcursor https://twitter.com/drcursor
- walterbell 8y agoIf you post a link here to the old thread, we can discuss there.