5 ms·
> That is the most logical as a fine is supoosed to be a deterrent and it does not deter if you are super rich. That is why that system doesn't work. For most
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> That is the most logical as a fine is supoosed to be a deterrent and it does not deter if you are super rich.
That is why that system doesn't work. For most things the required amount of deterrent doesn't depend on your income. For example, if it costs $100 to dispose of motor oil properly but $0 to dump it in the sewer then the fine has to be at least $100. But that means it needs to be at least $100 for everybody, or there will be people who find it profitable -- even to the point of setting up a "motor oil disposal" company where they dump everyone's motor oil in the sewer and then just pay the fines. But if you set the amount high enough that it deters the lowest income person and then scale it with income, you end up with unnecessarily draconian penalties on ordinary people.
It also becomes an obvious arbitrage opportunity. For example, if a rich person wants to travel fast by car then they get a low-income chauffeur so that the speeding fine is less. Income-based systems are always susceptible to this, where the super rich pay the cost of doing the arbitrage and what the system really ends up doing is hammering the middle class because they can't justify the arbitrage so they end up paying higher rates than the rich. See also corporate income tax, paid by local businesses but not huge international ones.
Finland only gets away with it because they have much less income inequality, and in particular much less poverty, so the ratio typically doesn't scale to the point that it starts causing huge problems like this.
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoThis is not an insurmountable hurdle. For people too poor to afford even the lowest fine, you can do something like community service at an effective pay rate of minimum wage in lieu of the fine. In the case of breaking the law for hire, you can make the employer jointly liable, as is already the case for most crimes.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> For people too poor to afford even the lowest fine, you can do something like community service at an effective pay rate of minimum wage in lieu of the fine. The problem is the opposite of that -- it isn't that the fine on low income people is too high, it's that it's too low to be a deterrent unless you make it high enough that scaling it makes is unnecessarily harsh for middle class people. > In the case of breaking the law for hire, you can make the employer jointly liable, as is already the case for most crimes. At which point you might as well just disband all large enterprises immediately because you've set up a system where you multiply the base rate of misbehavior by both the number of employees and the company's total revenue, which are both just proxies for size and so the penalty isn't just proportional, it's N-squared. You also can't avoid the problem unless you go all the way to the root of ownership or people will just outsource the activity to a shell company, but then you end up imposing a billion dollar fine for littering because the offender works for a company which is owned by a mutual fund.
- majewsky 8y ago> [The problem is when the fine is] too low to be a deterrent unless you make it high enough that scaling it makes is unnecessarily harsh for middle class people. Easy fix: Set the fine as "N times daily wage, but at least X".
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Easy fix: Set the fine as "N times daily wage, but at least X". At which point low and middle income people all pay the same fine or as close to it as makes no difference, rich people avoid it through arbitrage and you have a system with no significant effect (except maybe that the super rich still pay less than the upper middle class).
- skybrian 8y agoI'm not really seeing the downside of arbitrage. Do you have a better example? Rich people deciding not to drive and hiring professional drivers and/or using Uber, Lyft, or a taxi doesn't seem like a problem. The incentive worked. I doubt people driving as a business are all that eager to lose their license.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I'm not really seeing the downside of arbitrage. The downside is that you're failing to do the thing you set out to do. In theory the rich person (say $1,000,000 in income) places a high value on their time, so you impose a higher fine on them (say $20,000) to try to deter them. But the Uber driver only makes $20,000 total, so the fine for them is only $400. Meanwhile a middle class person making $50,000 pays $1000 -- 2.5X what the rich person incurs (assuming the fine the Uber driver pays is amortized over the fares). > Do you have a better example? Name basically anything that incurs a fine. A rich person who wants to do it and is "deterred" by the high fine just hires a poor person to do it for them. This is often what they do anyway because it saves them the labor independent of lowering the fine. > I doubt people driving as a business are all that eager to lose their license. But that has nothing to do with the fine, it's a separate penalty which doesn't exist in most other categories, apparently isn't sufficient (everybody speeds anyway), and the incentives of the driver and passenger are already aligned. They both want to get there faster, the passenger to save time, the driver so they can get another fare sooner.
- skybrian 8y agoIt does create jobs. And I didn't think the goal was to eliminate speeding, but rather to not do worse than average. A progressive fine isn't going to solve inequality.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> It does create jobs. Poverty-level jobs, by definition, because the prerequisite to being a good fine-sink is having a low income. > A progressive fine isn't going to solve inequality. The problem is that it makes it worse by effectively imposing higher fines on middle income people than the super rich.