3 ms·
My sister and I were both STAR Student (highest SAT score in our graduating high school class, top 20% GPA) and won National Merit Scholarships to UGA, one of t
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
My sister and I were both STAR Student (highest SAT score in our graduating high school class, top 20% GPA) and won National Merit Scholarships to UGA, one of the top two colleges in our home state. She took her scholarship and got her degree. I turned mine down, got married at age 19 to another 19 year old and spent two decades as a homemaker.
My sister began trying to have kids in her late twenties. She was 36 iirc when she finally had her only child. She has also miscarried multiple times.
She and I are no longer close, but we were at one time. We talked about the possibility of me serving as her surrogate if she couldn't have a child on her own.
Through her, I know quite a lot about fertility issues. I don't think I'm stretching anything. More like giving the nutshell version of many decades of knowledge.
- whorleater 8y ago>Through her, I know quite a lot about fertility issues. I empathize with your sister, but I think it's wrong to generalize a single data point over the population. On a broad level, birth rates in the US from 25-29 are at 104.3, whereas 30-34 is at 101.5[1]. This is a change, but far less in comparison to the dropoff at 35-39, where birth rates fall off a cliff to 51.8. If we take the article's premise at face value (college educated women in current times typically give birth at ~30 years old, vs non-college educated women at ~23), it would appear that the birth rate differences are negligible. [1]: https://data.cdc.gov/NCHS/NCHS-Birth-Rates-for-Females-by-Age-Group-United-S/yt7u-eiyg https://data.cdc.gov/NCHS/NCHS-Birth-Rates-for-Females-by-Ag...
- magic_beans 8y agoAre you married? I really hope your wife never experiences fertility issues. Fertility is much more complicated than data points.
- sidr 8y agoYes, let's ignore evidence based medicine because there might be some emotions involved. Nobody is arguiung that fertility is not complicated - there are multiple factors, but if you want to look at the effect of one particular factor (age) while controlling for others, I have no idea how to do it without data.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoIt's absolutely the case that it is easier for a younger woman to get pregnant than an older one (talking about a scale of years) . Fertility doesn't decline in a linear fashion but it does decline and to my knowledge, it doesn't ever increase over time. I think you need to reexamine what the stats you are quoting are really about.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoI think it could increase, if someone gave up smoking, drinking, started eating non-junk and sleeping. Haven’t looked at the science tho.
- gnulinux 8y agoData point N=1.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYou are misinterpreting my comment. She read quite a lot about fertility issues while pursuing fertility treatments. She forwarded me many articles on the topic and we talked a great deal about the subject. She's currently a high ranking employee at the CDC.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gred 8y ago> UGA, one of the top two colleges in our home state Hello, fellow Georgian! Having attended the other of these two colleges, I will avoid mentioning which one belongs in the #1 spot and which belongs in the #2 spot, and will instead just say that I have very much enjoyed reading your comments on this topic today.