4 ms·
Facebook didn't need much moderation until it started allowing strangers to enrage each other through public comments. My experience on FB is that 100% of the
by smt88 8y ago
Facebook didn't need much moderation until it started allowing strangers to enrage each other through public comments.
My experience on FB is that 100% of the value of the platform comes from parties I choose to engage with (friends, local businesses, groups), and almost all of that value is wiped out by having to see comments from trolls.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pasbesoin 8y agoRemember when "friends of friends" used to be a (readily accessible) setting? Now, it's "friends" or "public". Reflect on that, for a minute. "Friends of friends" isn't/wasn't perfect, but it had a moderating effect. A lot of this, is Facebook's own fault. Because greed.
- dlhavema 8y agoI'm guessing it was a lot harder for stuff to go viral when it was only "friends of friends" vs "public"... but i remember reading somewhere they throttle delivery of messages to friends until they can gauge feeedback.. not sure if that was confirmed or a rumor.
- javagram 8y agoDidn’t privacy researchers show that “friends of friends” was misleading and effectively public because of how easy it is to become a friend of a friend ?
- pasbesoin 8y agoI can imagine this, especially with friends who "friend all over the place". My own network of friends, and most of their friends, have remained much more contained. People who want to be in touch with real friends, not "products" or random encounters or "networking". However, did Facebook use this as an argument for their change? I've not seen them doing so. And I'm reminded of the whole "profile pictures are now forcibly changed to be public" policy, earlier. It may help people who don't know each other much and have no other avenue of communication, to "friend" each other. (Is that the right John/Jane Smith?) But, again in my anecdotal case, real friends can communicate out-of-band which is the right profile. They're already in touch; Facebook, just allows for asynchronous group sharing and discussion (or did, once upon a "simpler" time). The response to the "profile pictures must be public"? Those with privacy concerns no longer have a profile picture that shows them, if they ever did. Real names, too. That one helps to align collected data with data sales and advertising. And, for connecting less strong social connections. I understand the desire to "connect the world", especially in its more altruistic aspect. But, once again, Facebook quasi forced it. Whereas, social connections and sharing tend to work better when they are "opt in". Not opt out, or even no ability to opt out.
- Avshalom 8y agoIt's the passive/active question again. It might be trivial to actively become a fof but unlike public, it's not available unless you do take action. And every action is one extra filter.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoWhat do you mean by "trolls"? Someone who disagrees with you? Like half the country is "trolls"? And what stops you from simply unfriending these trolls, if they are so toxic? I'm not buying that narrative at all. What I think actually happened is that groups of people always had irreconcilable differences, but these groups were mostly physically separated, because people tend to form bubbles of like-minded people. But then FB came, and everyone's opinions became visible. Half of your coworkers that you went out drinking with turned out to be Trump supporters or antivaxxers, and that just makes you and them angry. The solution is to stop demonizing the other side, and start having rational conversations. But good luck with that. P.s. Calling them "trolls" will only drive them further away from your politics, you're helping Trump to get reelected.
- emodendroket 8y agoAnything short of enthusiastically agreeing with Trump someone will accuse you of being the reason Trump was elected. In one ear and out the other.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoThat's false. I disagree with Trump all the time, nobody ever told me I was the reason he got reelected.
- SllX 8y agoI'm not going to disagree with you, because what you say is spot on. What I am going to do is point out that hey, maybe there are people out there that troll just to troll or troll for a particular cause, and there's a lot of them. When you have a few different sides that are generally isolated from each other and already struggling to have a conversation and throw trolls and paid trolls (astroturfing) onto the same platform, you don't have a platform that is conducive to these various sides having any kind of conversation because there are groups of people that are actively working to prevent this. It doesn't even take a very strong push to keep them apart either, they were already inclined to isolate themselves in meatspace, why would cyberspace be any different? Facebook has more than a quarter of the Earth's population on their platform. Undoubtedly this is a hard problem to solve. An authoritarian approach is probably what they are going to end up having to go with because they're not a country or a religion, they're a bloody online advertising company.