7 ms·
USPTO likely to adopt 'peer-to-patent' (Feb 2010)
- tptacek 16y agoIsn't there some legal strategy reason why challenging patents is a bad idea? Like, the due process involved is minimal, and having survived a challenge, the facts behind the challenge strengthen the patent in court? I bring this up because I remember this being one of the big complaints about the current patent system, and "peer-to-patent" would appear to make that even worse.
- dctoedt 16y ago> Isn't there some legal strategy reason why challenging patents is a bad idea? Like, the due process involved is minimal, and having survived a challenge, the facts behind the challenge strengthen the patent in court? At the margin that's indeed a concern. Many patent attorneys think, however, that -- A) On average you're likely to get a better take on patentability from an examiner, who has at least some background in the technology and who doesn't have a presumption of validity to overcome; B) Suppose you have prior art that you think invalidates the claims of a patent application, but you withhold it from the patent applicant in hopes of using it later on as a defense in infringement litigation. The patent owner's trial counsel is likely to argue to the jury that your actions then speak louder than your words now. "If the prior art was so great," counsel will argue, "why didn't they give it to the patent applicant to be forwarded to the patent examiner? They're just trying to pull the wool over your eyes, and making you do extra work evaluating this supposedly-great prior art reference, when they could have saved you the trouble by having the examiner look at it in the first place."
- tptacek 16y agoDoes the latter argument actually work in court? Is it the expectation of courts that people will continually monitor patent applications looking for things to invalidate?
- Vivtek 16y agoThat's how I've always understood it. The examiner is supposed to check for prior art, but (1) it's hard and (2) that cuts into revenue. The fallback mechanism has always been the patent appeal - generally the appellant has an interest in voiding the patent or some of its claims for business reasons, but there's no reason you have to. So yes, it's the expectation of the courts that people will continually monitor granted patents and appeal them as necessary. And I guess patent applications as well.
- dctoedt 16y ago> So yes, it's the expectation of the courts that people will continually monitor granted patents and appeal them as necessary. I dunno about that. My sense is that a patent owner's counsel would not try to argue that the accused infringer had a general duty to monitor pending applications or issued patents. The argument would be, instead, that the circumstances suggest that the prior art in question wasn't so good after all. Keep in mind that jurors are usually non-technical. Therefore, patent litigators try hard to find understandable indirect- or circumstantial evidence that can get the message across to the jurors. EXAMPLE: If someone walks into the courtroom in a dripping-wet raincoat, that's indirect evidence of rain. EXAMPLE: Widespread imitation of an invention, or praise for it, is regarded as indirect evidence of nonobviousness. In this hypothetical, the patent owner's counsel argues that the defendant's failure to bring the supposedly-killer prior art to the attention of the patent examiner is indirect evidence. Of what? That the prior art wasn't so good after all, and that the defendant is trying to put one over on the jurors.
- Vivtek 16y agoWow. This goes to show you how easy it is to overestimate what you know - my patent experience is all about translating stuff from German (or French) into English, so now that I think about it, all the appeal documentation I've ever seen has been before the European patent appeals court. The thought of defending a patent in front of a "jury of your peers" is frankly something I never even thought of. The insidiousness of ignorance...
- prodigal_erik 16y agoThe way I've heard it, patent examiners must meet high quotas. Rejecting too many applications and fighting the inevitable appeals (which isn't counted equally as useful work for some reason, possibly because it doesn't bring USPTO very much revenue) can cost them their jobs, while there are basically no consequences (at least not for themselves or USPTO) for rubber-stamping applications that should rightfully be rejected. If your prior art can only be seriously considered one time, that's not who you want doing it, however qualified they might be.
- chaostheory 16y agoThere is if I remember correctly: if the entity applying for a patent places his patent on peer to patent for public review and it passes, I think the process for acquiring the patent will be much faster vs going the traditional route IANAL
- akeefer 16y agoMy understanding is that there are a few reasons why it can be a bad idea. First of all, prior art seems to be taken more seriously during the re-examinations that happen during lawsuits. If the prior art is presented beforehand and the patent is granted anyway, then that avenue is closed off. In addition, it gives the patent filer more of a chance to tweak their patent to try to work around the prior art and re-file it (often several times) until it gets granted. So you want to only present prior art during the phase of examination during which it's taken the most seriously and when the patent filer doesn't have an opportunity to game the process by refiling over and over again, which usually means waiting until it comes to trial. Secondly, patent attorneys don't like their clients doing any sort of search of/reading of any patents that could potentially affect their work. If you're found to have knowingly violated a patent, the damages are far greater than if you did it unknowingly. Submitting prior art to try to get a patent thrown out before it's granted would necessarily require researching and reading up on those very patents, so if the patent didn't get thrown out and you were eventually sued for infringing it, you'd be in much, much bigger trouble. Presumably the people who have the incentive and knowledge to bring up that prior art are likely to be involved in the same segment of the industry, which puts them in an awkward position: do you try to get the patent thrown out ahead of time, and be in serious trouble if you fail, or do you hope you don't end up at trial but keep the prior art in your back pocket in case you do? Perhaps big companies could have a dedicated legal arm to research and challenge such patents at arms-length from their developers and/or keep their developers aware of potential minefields, but for smaller companies you'd be better off avoiding patent searches or research altogether. That's fairly paradoxical given that patents are supposed to further innovation by giving people an incentive to disclose their inventions, but that's what the software patenting world has come to . . .
- tkeller 16y ago... eight months ago.
- IgorPartola 16y agoOnce again, prior art has nothing to do with it. Software patents are as ridiculous as patents on different colors of shoe laces. Software algorithms are mathematical expressions. I don't need to show prior art to prove that having a patent on 46,456,456 + 235,566 = 46,692,022 is meaningless even if nobody has done that particular calculation before me.
- nkassis 16y agoI'm no fan of software patents but comparing a simple arithmetic operation to an algorithm is a bad way to argue about software patents. Algorithms are a higher level of abstraction that can be quite complex in the end. And they are rarely the unique way to do something. It can even be almost impossible that an algorithm is really the best choice in your case. Do I think software patents (or any patents) make sense? No, but I won't call software algorithms simple mathematical expressions similar to adding 1+1.
- JabavuAdams 16y ago> Software algorithms are mathematical expressions. I don't need to show prior art to prove that having a patent on 46,456,456 + 235,566 = 46,692,022 is meaningless even if nobody has done that particular calculation before me. Straw-man argument by over-generalization. A better analogy would be that software systems are machines that can be fully specified in some formal system. But then, so are physical machines, for most useful levels of abstraction. The distinction is simply not as clear-cut as you're making it. If a software system can simulate a physical system, should there be a difference in patentability? If you're speaking narrowly of individual algorithms, then perhaps you have an argument, but what's important is how you pull all the various algorithms you need together.
- IgorPartola 16y agoAccording to Donald Knuth[1]: "[To a computer scientist] every algorithm is as mathematical as anything could be... An algorithm is an abstract concept unrelated to physical laws of the universe." [1]http://www.pluto.it/files/meeting1999/atti/no-patents/brevetti/docs/knuth_letter_en.html http://www.pluto.it/files/meeting1999/atti/no-patents/brevet...
- JabavuAdams 16y agoI finally realized the other day what I think is the core miscommunication between the pro-patent and anti-patent camps. Patents stifle innovation when capital costs are low to 0. If I can build something fun (and potentially commercializable) for $50 dollars + my time, then there's no way I'm going to spend multiple (ten) thousands of dollars to license someone's patent. The innovation dies right there. Yeah, these monopolies make sense if I have to set up a plant, or do years of research, but that's not true in software anymore. There's another factor at work. Creative types can't help but make things. They don't necessarily need a financial incentive to make stuff, nor would they want to get bogged down in those details. They make stuff because it's fun to do, and they have some (un)reasonable expectation of commercializing some projects. Great engineers make stuff even when no one is paying them. They can't help it.
- zacharypinter 16y agoThat's a very interesting point. It'd be fun to think about how one could architect a patent system where the duration and scope of a patent is based on the capital costs that went into developing it as well as the capital costs required for a clean room implementation (still seems silly that a patent can affect somebody else from coming up with the same idea independently).
- brlewis 16y agoExactly. Incentives are what the patent system is all about. More on this here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1724264 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1724264
- cybernytrix 16y agoQuick! file an app for 'peer-to-patent' and we'll be riiiiich!
- alok-g 16y agoThere are three requirements on an invention to be patentable -- It "must be new, non-obvious, and useful". All three clauses are important there. The proposal handles the "new" part only, and as IgorPartola suggests, it has issues. IgorPartola's argument "prior art has nothing to do with it" is still incorrect though since the "new" is still important. If the "new" part has difficulties, they can be more readily handled via litigation, provided both parties are given balanced opportunity to litigate (http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/eff_apache_software_foundation_and_microsoft_urge.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/eff_apache_software_fou...) A lot more difficult is to judge the "non-obvious" part. Many patents that should not have been issued fall in this category and would remain hard to handle even with litigation. Anyone has ideas on how to handle non-obvious part?
- SkyMarshal 16y agoI wrote the following as part of an email to the USPTO when it was requesting comments for Bilski Guidance a few weeks ago. I threw it together on the last day so it's not entirely well thought out, but I'm curious what's the HN take on the general idea of such a framework like this: "One framework for thinking about software patents is the Edison Criteria - inspiration vs perspiration. Thomas Edison said: 'None of my inventions came by accident. I see a worthwhile need to be met and I make trial after trial until it comes. What it boils down to is one per cent inspiration and ninety-nine per cent perspiration.' This statement illuminates the fact that there are several domains under which inventions can be categorized: 1. Easy/inexpensive to derive, and easy/inexpensive to implement or produce (ex: Amazon 1-click check out) 2. Easy/inexpensive to derive, and difficult/costly to implement or produce (Google Search) 3. Difficult/costly to derive, easy/inexpensive to implement or produce (pharmaceuticals) 4. Difficult/costly to derive, difficult/costly to implement or produce (Saturn V rocket, Large Hadron Collider) Easy and difficult are, of course, relative values, and there are certainly grey areas in between, not every invention or innovation falls neatly within one of these criteria. However, if the objective of the patent system is to promote the progress of science and useful arts, then I suggest the PTO allow patents only for #3 and #4, but not for #1 and #2." The idea is that #1 is obvious and easy - others would likely come up with the idea independently and implement it, creating competition, improvement, and falling prices. Patenting inventions in this area would hence harm progress in the 'useful arts'. #2 has a natural moat (cost of implementation) and hence does not need additional protection from patents, and may fail the obviousness test anyway. #3 is costly to derive and has no natural moat (as demonstrated by the generic drug industry) and hence needs additional patent protection to preserve the incentive to make the large investments required for progress in this domain. #4 is both costly and has a natural moat, and I'm not entirely sure how patents should apply here, but it's not relevant to issue of software patents and Bilski. What do you guys think of categorizing inventions/knowledge like this for purposes of deciding what can be patented or not?
- Vivtek 16y agoIf it's difficult to derive and produce, you're not likely to need patent protection. Patenting a large hadron collider would be money and thought wasted - it's a unique undertaking and people will come to you to use it anyway. The bleeping 1-click patent, though, God, it's enough to make my head explode if I think too much about that being patented. An utter perversion of the original intent of the patent system.