3 ms·
I often lament that the kind of empowerment things like Visual Basic --and before it QBasic, BASICA, and the 8-bit micro BASICs-- brought us pretty much no long
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago
I often lament that the kind of empowerment things like Visual Basic --and before it QBasic, BASICA, and the 8-bit micro BASICs-- brought us pretty much no longer exists in modern computing. Allowing people to easily build their own tools to solve their own problems is a big part of what personal computing is all about as far as I'm concerned, and there's just no effort put into it today.
Even on something like Linux, which you'd think would have a community favorable of the concept, you instead have a bunch of elitists declaring that only professional C greybeards should even be allowed to change the background color.
- jodrellblank 8y agoI feel that lament, but I wonder what problems people have now, that aren't more easily solved with an existing desktop program or an app? (implying that all easily solved problems have been solved many times over, which makes now different from the 1990s. And modern solutions are more complex to reflect more complex computing reality).
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoWhy do people still pipe commandline tools together to do things? Hasn't someone written a program to solve their problem? There are an infinite number of problems, and being able to construct your own tools to solve them is still enormously useful. It's one of the reasons Excel is still so popular. > modern solutions are more complex to reflect more complex computing reality This is a convenient lie developers tell themselves to justify their complexity fetish instead of thinking about how to simplify things.
- jodrellblank 8y agoThis is a convenient lie developers tell themselves to justify their complexity fetish instead of thinking about how to simplify things. VB dates back to 1991, with its last release in 1998. Before popular email, before people wanted high-res photo processing and music file tagging, before people wanted to write their own 3d games, before ordinary people wanted cross-platform tools, when everything was ASCII and that was fine, before people had cloud backups or wanted to cross-post their Wordpress blogs to Twitter, before they wanted to integrate with Philips Hue bulbs or have their code run on an rPI, or integrate with an XML web service or a REST API or download 10GB of mapping data and look for patterns in it. If you're going to argue that the computing landscape is no different to 20 years ago in complexity, and the tasks people want to do are no different, it's going to be a tough argument. But if you do argue that, then you have no problem because VB still exists and you can buy it on eBay. If you think nothing's changed, that should be as good a solution as it ever was, right? Why do people still pipe commandline tools together to do things? Hasn't someone written a program to solve their problem? Do ordinary people do that?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoProcessing 10GB of data is not fundamentally different from processing 1k of data. Copying data, whether to disk or the internet, again is not fundamentally different. Keeping data consistent was the same problem in 1980 as it is today. All that has changed is the scale. > Do ordinary people do that? Yet another excuse, imagining that the user is some drooling moron who never uses tools correctly and things must be as crap as they are because we have to cater to them. Linux desktop has been targeting this user for over a decade, where has it gotten them?
- jodrellblank 8y agoProcessing 10GB of data is fundamentally different, in the sense that the data you want to process is going to be more complex - many 1kb files, or a pile of structured map data or weather data or something that you aren't going to want to write your own parser for - there are surely more common data formats now than there were decades ago. Copying data to/from the internet isn't "fundamentally" different, it's normally different. Python requests module, Beautiful Soup, a good XML and JSON library will get you a lot further than plain VB code when working with internet things. It's not only scale which has changed, there's more kinds of things to do, and more existing popular large systems to tie into, and the desire to make use of more existing libraries to build on. Yet another excuse, imagining that the user is some drooling {disinterested person} who never uses tools correctly That pretty much is my experience of non-geeks using computers. things must be as crap as they are because we have to cater to them. Linux desktop has been targeting this user for over a decade, where has it gotten them? As I said, you claim VB is some pinnacle of computing which we've lost, but it's still there. You also claim that nothing has changed and nothing needs to be different, so I'm still at a loss how you can then say that there's nothing today like VB was for normal people. If VB exists and you think nothing is different .. what's wrong?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I often lament that the kind of empowerment things like Visual Basic --and before it QBasic, BASICA, and the 8-bit micro BASICs-- brought us pretty much no longer exists in modern computing. But, it does: tools that are superior to these in almost every imaginable dimension (including the ease by which a novice can ramp up if they devote energy to it) are bundled with most desktop/laptop OSs, and, a couple clicks away in the app stores of at least one of the two major mobile platforms. There is a complete lack of interest in most of the userbase, though.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoBullshit. There is nothing like what VB6 was being shipped with anything today. PowerShell or Python are about as close as you get to BASIC in terms of things that are shipped with the OS, but they're an order of magnitude or more as complicated and do basically nothing as far as creating GUIs, which really aught to be much much more straightforward in 2018 than it is.