2 ms·
> The author makes the point that, when companies spend so much on stock buybacks they don't have reserves to keep things running in economic downturns, thus le
by philwelch 8y ago
> The author makes the point that, when companies spend so much on stock buybacks they don't have reserves to keep things running in economic downturns, thus leaving them in grave danger should recession come around, and leaves their employees more exposed than they need to be. I think this is a point worth talking about, especially if you feel it's not true, because by calling it a meme and not countering it, you've given no chance to bat for your own opinion and offering counterpoints.
OK, let's address that argument.
The alternative to stock buybacks is stock dividends. Both of those mechanisms deplete corporate cash reserves, but stock buybacks do them in a way that causes the stock value to appreciate, which has tax benefits for shareholders that outright dividends do not. If there's no potential for corporations to distribute their cash reserves to their shareholders at all, then there is no point in having a stock market in the first place.
> For example, Musk wants to take Tesla private because he feels the quarterly stock review cycle restricts his ability to innovate and think long term. Musk is quite the capitalist, so I think the idea that optimizing for share price being bad for productivity is certainly worth presenting at the table.
There are countless businesses, including some of the most valuable public businesses in the world, for whom the quarterly review cycle is not an impediment to innovation and success. Musk is probably humiliated that Tesla is running out of money and has not been doing a good job of handling the transparency involved in having a publicly owned company.