3 ms·
I understand that buybacks are good for executives and good for buy-and-hold shareholders. Executives benefit because a large part of their comp is tied to stoc
by gnicholas 8y ago
I understand that buybacks are good for executives and good for buy-and-hold shareholders. Executives benefit because a large part of their comp is tied to stock performance. So if companies couldn't do buybacks all of a sudden, executives would have less comp. Shareholders benefit because they can defer the taxes until they sell – instead of paying taxes each year on dividends.
If companies were prevented from buying back stock, then executives would ask for their compensation packages and targets to be restructured to take this into account. So at the end of the day, executives would get the same amount of benefit, more or less.
Ordinary buy-and-hold shareholders wouldn't be able to rejigger their affairs in the same way, so they'd be somewhat worse off. It's not clear to me that this solves any big problems though...
- vkou 8y agoFor every tax dollars that this structuring saves long-term investers, that's one extra dollar that average Joe, who owns 0-10k in stock, has to pay.
- Nokinside 8y agoIs average Joe in US free from taxes from dividends if he reinvests? If not, then it's bad for him too.
- vkou 8y agoHe has very few savings to invest, and derives almost no benefits from this, compared to his wealthy neighbour. Tax advantages for shareholders are a transfer of wealth from the poor to the rich.
- ryandrake 8y agoAround 50% of Americans hold no stock at all, including indirect holdings like pensions, 401k etc.
- gnicholas 8y ago> Tax advantages for shareholders are a transfer of wealth from the poor to the rich. You can call this a wealth transfer, but only if you're willing to accept that every decision in the tax code is a wealth transfer. Graduated rates? Wealth transfer to the poor. Lower rates for long-term capital gains? Wealth transfer to the rich. Refundable tax credits? Wealth transfer to the poor. Unfortunately, going down this road isn't terribly productive from a tax policy perspective since it doesn't actually tell us what the right choices to make are. Where should LTCG rates be, compared to OI rates? Should they be subject to FICA/Med withholding? How do we weigh this against the desire to incentivize people to save? It's not as simple as labeling everything as a wealth transfer in one direction or the other.
- gnicholas 8y agoThat's true, but the title isn't "End Stock Buybacks, Save Average Joe". The authors haven't made a particularly convincing case that following their suggestion would save the economy.