7 ms·
Is this a real problem or just a tempest in a teapot? Many anecdotes != data. About the only thing that popped out at me is the line "She makes about $1,400 a
by r00fus 8y ago
Is this a real problem or just a tempest in a teapot? Many anecdotes != data.
About the only thing that popped out at me is the line "She makes about $1,400 a month after taxes, but nearly half of it goes to the rent on her one-bedroom apartment."
Maybe housing costs are what's causing the slump (if there is one)? Around where I live I see stores closing all the time and I'd bet the #1 reason is that rent is too damn expensive.
- BadassFractal 8y agoSounds like a very common story of people living in SF, NY, LA, Seattle, Portland etc. unless they're very successful, even by the standards of that city. I hear the same can be said of Paris, London, Berlin, Moscow, Tokyo, Hong Kong etc. Shoot, having a place all to yourself is one heck of a luxury in those cities. Plenty of people there are having to skip nice things if they want to live in a place like that. All while paying off student loans, while their careers are still in the early stages.
- jacobolus 8y agoOne reason that property values have gone up in these places is that property in world cities is now often used as an investment vehicle for foreigners who made fortunes in politically unstable places, and want to park their money somewhere safe, or at least diversified. This kind of investment is problematic even when the money’s source is legitimate. Having housing owned by absentee landlords who live halfway around the world is mostly negative for a city’s residents (though might benefit some local property owners whose property values are thereby inflated). Remote owners for the most part don’t care about maintaining their property, improving the local neighborhood or city, forming relationships with tenants, etc., and sometimes even leave units unoccupied for extended periods of time, taking housing stock off the market. I hope governments figure out some way to impose substantial additional taxes on non-owner-occupied housing, especially when it gets to large scale, or when units are kept unoccupied. The purpose of housing is to provide a place for people to live, not to build a fortune for a few capitalists, especially ones who are not local and are therefore largely unaccountable for bad behavior.
- ggm 8y agoOne reason that property values have gone up in these places is that property in world cities is now often used as an investment vehicle for foreigners who made fortunes in politically unstable places, and want to park their money somewhere safe, or at least diversified. Often those fortunes were embezzled from public coffers or built on criminal enterprises, and real estate is a magnet for money laundering. But this kind of investment is problematic even when the money’s source is legitimate. Sure, if you want to talk about Colombian narco-dollars, or Russian keptocracy. China has a huge middle class, who worked all their life and had mandated government savings, with a pension for women at age 55. Please, do not write down all foreign investment in property to stolen money: Chinese purchasors in the west of small to medium size flats, and houses are buying for three reasons 1) the cost of property in Beijing is too high 2) their children are doing masters or phd programmes in the economy and its sensible to invest and save the kid rental 3) they want an exit strategy for their life savings if things go bad in the home country They are not kleptocrats. This is not stolen money. This is 30 or 40 years of savings, coupled to insane property bubbles. [Edit] I know some of them. I talk to them about this. I am not reporting from things I read, this is what I know from my neighbours in my apartment complex.
- jacobolus 8y agoBy no means is all (or even most) foreign investment stolen money (though there is a lot of corrupt money sloshing around, including a lot from China). However, even just “middle class” millionaire foreign investors parking money in international real estate is highly problematic for the places where the houses are. As an example, my parents live in a quiet suburb of Los Angeles, and recently a few of the neighboring houses were bought by foreign investors. Maintenance has all but stopped. One house was rented long-term to a group of college students who used it as a party house. Tenants move in and out of those houses within a year or two instead of staying long term. Any communication goes through a scummy property management company. If a critical mass of houses get like that, the neighborhood becomes a much different place. Everything becomes transactional and low-trust. The only way to get stuff fixed is by filing formal complaints or threatening legal action. Minor problems just pile up because it’s not worth the trouble. People stop caring about making things pleasant, or even making them work. Remote owners and management companies are just there to make a buck, and tenants are just temporarily stopping through for a place to sleep while they work out something more permanent elsewhere.
- redahs 8y ago> Maybe housing costs are what's causing the slump (if there is one)? Yes, that's how the business cycle has worked in western countries since the classical antiquity. The largest component of urban housing costs is the price for access to land, and payments for access to land are surplus payments beyond what is necessary for land to be supplied, because land is a fixed a natural resource with no labor cost of production. An increase in land banking and the holding of real estate for investment purposes decreases the supply of land available, increases payments for access to it. This increases the market valuations for real estate value based on the increase in the capitalized value of future rent payments. This increases the opportunity cost of investing money in productive businesses which employ labor to produce goods and services relative to putting money into land. This decreases investment in production of non-land goods and services which have a labor cost of production, which decreases the demand for labor, which decreases wages. Decreased wages then lead to decreased consumption which leads to decreased ability to pay rent, which then results in a drop in property valuations based upon capitalized rent payments. After a sustained period of rents increasing faster than wages, the property bubble usually pops and results in an economic depression. One solution to avoid this problem is through taxing and redistributing surplus land rents through a land value tax, which countries such as Taiwan have implemented. China has people smart enough to clear this hurdle and find creative solutions to continue rapid growth, but since Xi has consolidated power and gone back to heavily promoting Marxism as the economic model for China's future, the current political situation makes it seem unlikely that they will actually do so.
- baybal2 8y agoFYI, netting $1400 a month in China is freaking a lot for somebody who is not an engineer or a communist. An average fancy lunch costs CNY25 in the most expensive part of the town. Living a careless life on $700 per month can be done effortlessly. To note, China is a freaking HIGH tax country. Earning $1400 post tax means her gross income must be around CNY25000 with freebies and perks, which makes her into top 5% of the workforce. She earns almost as much as engineers do.
- contingencies 8y agoYour numbers are out of date. In 2002 I recall eating a huge bowl of noodles in rural Yunnan for CNY1. Today an average "fancy lunch" costs at least CNY60 in a Tier 1 city. Hell, even one beer usually costs that. That's USD$10. In Shenzhen, an average bowl of noodles is CNY20+. (The cheapest of the cheap, if you can find it and are willing to eat it, is about CNY8-16.) In the airports it's CNY60+ nationally. In high speed trains nationally a central kitchen produced low quality mass-meal in a thermoform container is CNY45, and perhaps purchased by 1/3 of travelers. For more reference prices take a look at http://ele.me/ http://ele.me/ delivery service. The delivery fees alone are around CNY7 (USD$1+). This is not "fancy lunch in the most expensive part of town" but "the stuff the average white collar worker eats daily".
- baybal2 8y agoNo... These are prices in an award winning place in downtown Shenzhen https://imgur.com/a/XqTC9zE https://imgur.com/a/XqTC9zE For a snob, one can go to Michelin rated Putien where you can get few very satiating dishes under CNY40
- contingencies 8y agoA few places is not the same as the market as a whole. Regarding your example: yes, you can order some tofu for 23元 but you will need three such dishes for one person to feel sated and such places have minimum order sizes for delivery that typically exceed 2 dishes. (So at your example place, 3 x 25元 average dish price = 75元 per head, plus delivery fee) PS. Downtown Shenzhen is called Futian (福田; "abundant fields") not Putien (which is not even Pinyin, suggesting you are an overseas Chinese person or foreigner with little mainland exposure). I have been based here for most of the last 18 years.