4 ms·
I think calling their language "deliberately misleading" is deliberately misleading when there is a representative from the project here telling you that they d
by sanderjd 8y ago
I think calling their language "deliberately misleading" is deliberately misleading when there is a representative from the project here telling you that they do not intend to mislead (thus even if it is misleading, it isn't deliberate). But I guess you just seem comfortable calling that person a liar. From reading this one thread, it seems like a bummer to me that you're assuming bad faith. But I had never heard of Dgraph until this thread, so maybe there is history that I'm naively ignoring.
- Sir_Cmpwn 8y agoYes, I'm willing to be frank and state explicitly that I'm calling this person a liar.
- sanderjd 8y agoWhat's your history with them that leads you to this conclusion? If you don't have any, and you're simply making assumptions based on their choice of licensing terms, what would your argument look like if you instead imagined them as people acting in good faith, trying to provide software to people on terms that allow them to both continue improving the software while also providing for their families? I guess the reason I have trouble assuming bad faith with things like this is because it would be much easier for these people to just get high paying jobs at big software companies than to try to eke out a living making a useful source-provided (it would be so much easier to just use "open source" here, but that is verboten) product while arguing with people like you.
- Sir_Cmpwn 8y agoI think I've explained myself quite well in the thread. My personal, subjective conclusion is of dishonesty. I cannot give you an objective measure, the evidence is in this thread and you can draw your own conclusions. Being a generally good person who is trying to put food on the table for their family is not mutually exclusive with lying and resorting to questionably ethical means of doing so.
- sanderjd 8y agoI've (unfortunately) read the whole thread. You've jumped to an uncharitable conclusion. A bunch of people have pointed this out. You can disagree while assuming good faith. It's too bad you aren't doing that here. I agree with you that it isn't a very good choice for licensing terms.
- Sir_Cmpwn 8y ago>You can disagree while assuming good faith Yes, but bad faith exists, and the assumption of good faith is not always appropriate. I don't think that Dgraph is operating in good faith, and the evidence is enough that I am unable to suspend my disbelief. If I were Dgraph and my actions were so severely wrong that people were assuming bad faith, I would want to quickly correct that. But in fact, most of the concerns have gone un-answered.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> think calling their language "deliberately misleading" is deliberately misleading when there is a representative from the project here telling you that they do not intend to mislead (thus even if it is misleading, it isn't deliberate). Well, yes, of you assume the honesty of the person being accused of being deliberately misleading, then that forces you to reject the claim that they are being deliberately misleading, but that is also a prime example of circular reasoning.
- sanderjd 8y agoDidn't I speak directly to that in the part of my comment you didn't quote? I guess I was being too cute in my comment, so I'll switch to frankness. As a total outsider to all this, your and others' assumption of bad faith and willingness to accuse people of outright lies here is very unconvincing and off-putting to me. I think they're probably just trying to make a living off of software they put a lot of time into creating. It's reasonable to disagree about their approach, but you're uncharitably going further than that.
- richard75 8y agoYou should do some homework first. https://blog.dgraph.io/post/licensing/ https://blog.dgraph.io/post/licensing/ They claim that Dgraph started with the idea that every startup should be able to have the same level of technology as run by big giants. They started with VC funding in 2016 and their goal was always to make money. That is clearly biggest lie. There is no harm in creating a company for profit but i would appreciate if they were honest. The only reason Dgraph is open source is to get early adopters and free testers and contribution from community.
- sanderjd 8y agoI'm so confused, what part are you saying is a lie? The whole post is focused around "building a long lasting company" through having a sustainable business model. What is dishonest about that? Aiming to provide good technology to startups and aiming to make money are not contradictory!