6 ms·
This is not trolling. I honestly ask: why is TCK important? How does it prevent Apache Harmony from ever shipping a "real release"? After all, before OpenJDK, G
by sanxiyn 16y ago
This is not trolling. I honestly ask: why is TCK important? How does it prevent Apache Harmony from ever shipping a "real release"? After all, before OpenJDK, GCJ and lots of other free Java implementations released fine without TCK.
- pilif 16y agothe problem is that Sun/Oracles patent license only covers implementations that passed TCK. Conversely, by not passing TCK you don't get their patent license. Many of the patents in question are difficult (if even possible) to work around if you were to create your alternate implementation. This means that using any non TCK implementation of Java makes you liable for patent lawsuits (as seen with the Google case).
- sanxiyn 16y agoAh, so anyone using GCJ in a product could be sued the same way Google was sued. I didn't know that. The right conclusion to make seems to be that software patents are bad.
- bad_user 16y agoThe other conclusion would be that Sun, and now Oracle, are schizophrenic hypocrites: let's not blame it solely on software patents.
- pilif 16y ago> Ah, so anyone using GCJ in a product could > be sued the same way Google was sued. I > didn't know that. this is exactly the point. And this might also be (one of) the reason(s) why Google PR is calling the suit against them a suit against Open Source in itself.
- rbanffy 16y agoI believe the GCJ is vulnerable because, like Dalvik, it's not derived from the OpenJDK.
- hga 16y agoWell, not being VM based it should be free of some or all of the patents used by Oracle in that part of its lawsuit against Dalvik, but that doesn't mean that it wouldn't be otherwise vulnerable.
- rbanffy 16y agoAnd don't forget OpenJDK derivatives are only patent-proof for patents owned by Sun at the time of its licensing.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 16y ago> the problem is that Sun/Oracles patent license only covers implementations that passed TCK. Can they do that, being the OpenJDK GPL-licensed? IIRC, it shields the OpenJDK, as well as GPL-licensed derivatives, from patent lawsuits. It doesn't protect Apache/MIT/BSD-licensed implementations, but who cares, if there is a GPL-licensed implementation available?
- pilif 16y agoyou are right, derivates of OpenJDK are shielded. Clean-room reimplementation are not though. Harmony was created to have a non-GPL implementation (and was used by Google for that reason)
- rbanffy 16y agoIf, for no other reason, we should love the GPL for rendering Oracle toothless. :-)
- pilif 16y agounless they don't TCK certify OpenJDK 7. Then we're back at square one.
- rbanffy 16y agoNo. As long as it's OpenJDK-derived and GPL-licensed, all JDK 7 features can be added.
- nitrogen 16y agoNo. Only features that don't infringe additional patents can be added by the community. If Oracle owns patents covering a particular Java 7 feature, but never releases any GPL code implementing that feature, then the OpenJDK community cannot implement that feature. Releasing code under the GPL does not give the open source community carte blanche access to all your future patents, perhaps unless those patents are necessarily infringed by the original GPL release.
- va_coder 16y agoI would also add the question: If I'm running Java on the server to deliver Web services, who cares? It's still open source, I have no plans to distribute MyPersonalVM that can run Java. Google is the one that wants to keep it's advertisement machine going. It matters to them that over the next few years an open and mobile competitor is around. It doesn't matter to me.
- hga 16y agoThe author pointed out that Sun/Oracle's posture is not resulting in as healthy an ecosystem as other languages with multiple independent free implementations.
- va_coder 16y ago"These multiple implementations of the languages are creating innovation on their respective platforms." He also criticized the JVM. "not resulting in as healthy an ecosystem" No ecosystem? Clojure, Lucene/Solr, Cassandra, Groovy, Hadoop to name a few are all part of this excellent ecosystem. Edit: There's some serious group think in HN. It seems any kind of alternate opinion gets immediately down modded. You may disagree with my opinion, but it is a valid and relevant opinion: Is all this lawsuit crap between the MegaCorps relevant to the average developer using Java for services?
- davidw 16y agoIf the average developer would prefer to develop for Android rather than Java ME, I think it is indeed relevant.
- va_coder 16y agoTo you it is very relevant. I'm just saying let's clarify who has a dog in this fight. Believe it or not, I'm using Solr, Groovy and Clojure and in my eyes the (approved || sanctioned || blessed) JVM has never a better platform.
- hugh4life 16y ago"After all, before OpenJDK, GCJ and lots of other free Java implementations released fine without TCK." GCJ is old... and OpenJDK does have access to the TCK IIRC...
- sanxiyn 16y agoGCJ is old, but is there any other implementation that can compile to native code? (Mainly good for simplifying distribution and better interfacing with native code instead of JNI.)
- hugh4life 16y agoExcelsior JET... is an AOT compiler... http://www.excelsior-usa.com/jet.html http://www.excelsior-usa.com/jet.html It is licensed...
- koenigdavidmj 16y agoIf I recall correctly, GCJ's `compiling to native code' really means `slapping a bytecode interpreter and your bytecode in the same file, and calling it an executable'.
- rmathew 16y agoThis is not correct at all. It generates actual native code from Java source files or byte-code.
- bad_user 16y ago> OpenJDK does have access to the TCK Of course it does, access to the TCK was always at Sun's discretion to give. OpenJDK doesn't matter, Java is not free to be implemented by open-source projects (even though JSR 270 explicitly says so) because the TCK licensing prohibits it. It is also irrelevant if GCJ is old, patents don't have a "use it or you'll lose it" clause as trademarks do.