5 ms·
...it’s going to get stranger and more frantic if Microsoft once again becomes a big player in the mobile space. If they get there, will they use their power to
by stcredzero 16y ago
...it’s going to get stranger and more frantic if Microsoft once again becomes a big player in the mobile space. If they get there, will they use their power to try and bend the carriers to their will? Or will they take the Google approach and let them walk all over the place dictating features and bloatware?
If M$ doesn't bend carriers to their will, then they might end up with crappy software on superior hardware. Not only does Microsoft have to guard against design-by-committee from within, it has to deal with the same from the carriers. In other words, Microsoft has to fight its DNA to be beautiful, while Apple just has to follow their usual tendencies. On the other hand, individual companies in the Android space can decide where they fall in the luxury/bargain spectrum.
Apple vs. Android is cathedral vs. bazaar. Is Windows Phone 7 going to be another cathedral, a bazaar, or will it be a half-assed combination of the two?
(Note that cathedrals took advantage of the efforts of several generations of individual workers adding their own contributions, but in a way which fit the whole. In other words, cathedrals were also a kind of ecosystem!)
The mobile space is about to be a full-on gun fight. And at least Microsoft seems to have walked into the middle of it with the right weapon.
A 3-way standoff? Who's the Good, The Bad, and The Ugly?
- froo 16y agoIs Windows Phone 7 going to be another cathedral, a bazaar, or will it be a half-assed combination of the two? I was thinking about this, I imagine the midpoint between a cathedral and a bazaar could possibly be a shopping mall... How profitable do shopping malls tend to be? They might have something, if only because they're doing something different with enough marketing steam behind them.
- megablast 16y agoI would not call Apple vs Android as cathedral vs bazaar, more Cathedral against lots of little annoying Cathedrals who want to extract every cent from you and disable functions on your phone to do that. Clearly Apple = Good (they started this new smartphone revolution, and care more about consumers than careers), Windows = Bad (will do anything to try to maintain their monopoly), and Google = Ugly (not really ugly, but they seem to be letting the carriers have more control).
- recoiledsnake 16y ago>If M$... I thought Hacker News was above the juvenile 'M$' but guess I was wrong. >Is Windows Phone 7 going to be another cathedral, a bazaar, or will it be a half-assed combination of the two? Right now it looks like a good combination. Good variety in hardware(for example, phones with real keyboard unlike the iPhone) while still retaining the ability to directly update the software(no shipping of old versions that take ages to get updated, if they get done at all, like Android).
- raganwald 16y agoHow is "M$" juvenile? It is a nickname I have seen from many adults but never from children. Do you mean "immature; childish; infantile?" as the dictionary suggests? I don't see hows. It implies to me that the person using the nickname claims that Microsoft is motivated entirely or largely by making money at the expense of all other considerations. It's cut from the same cloth as "MSFT," which implies they value their stock price above all else (this would appear to be wrong, based on the stock's performance, but there you go). You or I may not agree wit the characterization, but I hardly see this as immature. Informal, perhaps, in comparison to writing "Microsoft (who worship at the Temple of Mammon)..." But I don't see it as childish and juvenile. There is another possibility. If "M$" has been regularly used by people who are juvenile in other ways, perhaps using "M$" in trollish flamewars and ad hominem diatribes, it can become guilty through association with juvenile rants. Is that the problem here? That the nickname has been used so often by people acting in a juvenile way that it has unpleasant overtones you perceive that are invisible to someone like myself who doesn't share your life experience?
- NickPollard 16y agoUsing M$ is pretty much a defacto ad hominem - it means you're leading your position by saying 'Microsoft only care about money', and then using that to argue that there must be a problem with their products, without backing up or clarifying that assertion. Imagine if people started their posts with 'Facebook, who hate privacy, have just...', or 'Apple, who hate freedom, have now...', or 'Google, who are spying on you, are about to...' That would be pretty pathetic.