3 ms·
> The philosophy behind plan 9 is radically different from some of the ways things are done in Linux, and it would take a great effort to get this even close to
by davidw 16y ago
> The philosophy behind plan 9 is radically different from some of the ways things are done in Linux, and it would take a great effort to get this even close to production grade.
So it's not just "NIH and ego", it's the fact that people are loath to abandon working software for benefits that probably seem somewhat abstract?
The "crossing the chasm" approach is to find a niche where your product can win and then go from there. Taking on Linux head-on is just not going to be a winning proposition.
- jacquesm 16y agoIt was NIH and ego that stopped adoption from some of the more advanced knowledge available at the time when the relevant portions of linux were developed. There was no 'working software' to abandon at the time, there is now.
- davidw 16y agoPlan 9 came much later than Linux, if I'm not mistaken. Things like microkernels were around then, sure, but is Plan 9 interesting because its a microkernel or because of how you interact with it and how it's architected (everything is really a file)? Edit: it appears that Plan 9 existed internally at Bell labs at about the same time Linux was being developed, but was only released to the public, under a commercial license, in 1995. It was finally open sourced only a few years back. Also, there certainly was plenty of existing Unix software out there when Linux (and BSD) came out. Not nearly as much as now, but nothing to laugh at either.
- jacquesm 16y agoDon't forget minix and the Tanenbaum / Linus exchanges. That's a pretty well documented era, and guess what, Tanenbaum was right. But Linus was riding high on the momentum that he'd generated and Tanenbaum lost the popularity contest. But that didn't make him wrong, and over time those few disadvantages that have been trotted out as the reasons why he was wrong have all been put to rest. That's part hindsight, but Tanenbaum had a huge amount of experience and was already ahead of 'conventional' unix. Some people think he wasn't ahead enough, but it was certainly a step forward from where linux is, even today.
- davidw 16y ago> Don't forget minix and the Tanenbaum / Linus exchanges. That's what my 'microkernels' comment was referencing. > Tanenbaum was right. That is not clear to me. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tanenbaum%E2%80%93Torvalds_debate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tanenbaum%E2%80%93Torvalds_deba... Microkernels haven't exactly swept the world before them. Apparently, MacOS X and Windows NT based systems have some microkernel in their DNA, but it is my understanding that you couldn't really call them microkernels at this point.
- jacquesm 16y agoTanenbaum was right that linux was a giant step back in to the 70's. Microkernels have swept the world before them in a way that you can't even imagine, in the embedded systems world where 'failure is not an option' microkernels rule supreme without any threat from larger stuff. When you want deterministic hard real time with very tight upper boundaries on latency then a micro kernel will help tremendously. Everything else is subordinate to the scheduler, even things that in 'monoliths' are part of the kernel, such as IO driver running as user processes.
- acqq 16y ago> Tanenbaum was right Citation needed. Where do you get that? Performance-wise the biggest problem of OS X is still that part that is based on the "many servers are the OS" idea. That's the reason why this exists: http://www.ertos.nicta.com.au/software/darbat/ http://www.ertos.nicta.com.au/software/darbat/ Also, NT wanted to try moving in that direction but the critical parts are not "many servers." Also, there's a reason why L4 was developed (note: post Tanenbaum): the "real" microkernels were very problematic performance-wise and it's actually harder to produce them (example: Gnu Hurd) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L4_microkernel_family http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L4_microkernel_family http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_Hurd http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_Hurd
- eru 16y agoOn the other hand, you can view the current fad of virtualized everything and hypervisors as a kind of exokernel.
- pmarin 16y agoPlan9 is not microkernel.
- davidw 16y agoOops, sorry, good point.
- jacquesm 16y agoI've gone through an 'alternative operating system' phase at some point and played around with all kinds of them. I don't even think minix is a micro-kernel (Tanenbaum thinks it is), but QnX definitely is the real deal. There are some very interesting concepts in Plan 9 that linux could have taken advantage of though.
- davidw 16y ago> There are some very interesting concepts in Plan 9 that linux could have taken advantage of though. Given what I posted above, it's not clear that Plan 9 was really on Linus' radar when he started or in the formative years of Linux. When Plan 9 came out, radically changing Linux might have been a significant departure from a working system with a growing amount of software available for it.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]