3 ms·
If only one in a thousand stars have planets that can support life, only a thousandth of them develop complex life, only a thousandth of them avoid extinction e
by simonh 8y ago
If only one in a thousand stars have planets that can support life, only a thousandth of them develop complex life, only a thousandth of them avoid extinction events, only a thousandth of them develop technology, only a thousandth of them avoid destroying themselves somehow.
That would give us about one civilisation in every 10,000 galaxies. There are actually a lot more possible stages than that too, I've seen estimates that reasonably put our existence in the observable universe at all as a low probability event and maybe they're right. I've swung either way over the decades. There is a reasonable case that long term technological civilizations might be extremely rare. It's not a foregone conclusion that we are one of many.
Personally, I have no idea. It could go either way, but the Fermi Paradox does tend to indicate in the pessimistic direction at least with regard to our own galaxy. The problem is once you say technological life is rare at the one galaxy level, it only takes a few extra stages and a few extra low probability multipliers to make any life anywhere pretty unlikely.
- FireBeyond 8y agoYou leave out the time dimension. The universe is what, just under 14 billion years old, and intelligent life on earth that can meaningfully seek out such things is what, 100 years? That's another remarkably small window in time for us to discover anything - what if a civilization died out a million years ago?
- Razengan 8y ago> You leave out the time dimension. What if a civilization died out a million years ago? This is what I keep bringing up when referring to dinosaurs, and I'm surprised that this point doesn't get presented more often when considering the chances of encountering life on other planets: We have proof right here that life on the same planet can be separated by time and never contact each other, without even bringing cosmic distances into the equation.
- simonh 8y agoYou’re talking as though the dinosaurs and us are deparate life though. We are descendants of the dinosaurs - were the same life.
- simonh 8y agoFair point, the odds I gave are for these things to happen in the lifetime of a star. It seems likely though that Stars of previous generations than ours are unlikely to have had enough heavy elements to have a rich enough material environment to develop life. An abundant supply of heavier elements such as iron, potassium, calcium, etc is a relatively recent development in the universe. Planets lacking plentiful supplies of mid-weight elements seem like they would be dramatically less likely to develop life.