5 ms·
Your statement is far too broad and lacks context. Where is this a violation and where is it considered fraud? There must be some countries where this isn't the
by mosselman 8y ago
Your statement is far too broad and lacks context. Where is this a violation and where is it considered fraud? There must be some countries where this isn't the case or at least where the article and non-commercial use of the technique are considered to be mitigating circumstances.
Also, who doesn't find it cool? You don't seem to be saying that what is described in the article isn't cool, you seem to be making a broader claim that copyright violation and fraud aren't cool.
Lets assume you find what is described in this article copyright violation and fraud, because after all, you said it is. Apparently some people on HN find what the author has done cool, judging by the comments. Ergo, some things that you, specifically, consider 'copyright violation and fraud' are in fact cool.
- fabricexpert 8y agoHe copied Google's SERP page, AND copied all of his competitors websites. That's definitely copyright infringement, you'd be livid if you were a competitor, and as a user you'd be pretty annoyed. It's still an interesting hack, so good to see it being talked about. But it is not ethical and definitely illegal in almost any jurisdiction.
- EdwardDiego 8y agoCopyright infringement is a civil case in almost any jurisdiction, not a criminal case. The USA is a notable exception, perhaps due to the vested interests with deep pockets.
- fabricexpert 8y agoA civil case you would lose though.
- jakoblorz 8y agoJust to be clear: you do not endorse copyright infringement for the sake of being cool, do you?
- mosselman 8y agoI believe much of modern copyright law in Europe but especially the US is broken, but in general I don't find crime cool, nor do I find 'cool' a justification in itself to do certain things. Not all laws are sacred though. I was merely reacting to broad nature of the claims in parent comment. There is a world beyond the US and Europe, laws are not universal truths, they are a representation of what we have come to agree upon as rules to play by. In copyright law specifically though there is often a chasm between what the people find good rules and what companies find good rules. But that is a different discussion.