3 ms·
> Because you continue to ignore debt. Actually, I'm not, because last I checked, debt was amortized in nominal terms. >It's also a good example of how to lie
by dnautics 16y ago
> Because you continue to ignore debt.
Actually, I'm not, because last I checked, debt was amortized in nominal terms.
>It's also a good example of how to lie with statistics. For a 50k salary, my expenses dropped 4500 a year, nice, but my 200k house just went 20k in the hole as it's now worth only 180k but I still owe 200k. I can throw the entire 4500 savings at paying down the debt, but the net effect is that I'm still down 15.5k; ouch. Debt and deflation do not mix well.
What? No. The assumption there is that you are going to resell the house. If your plan is to keep it, then your amortization is still done in nominal terms. So what, (I know home mortgages are usually 30 years but let's make it 20 with a fixed 5% interest so the math is easy), your annual payment is gonna be 20k without deflation and 20k with deflation. Backtracking your math... The person was spending 45k on day to day expenses, so each year was going in the hole (45 + 20 - 50) = -15k per the first year. The next year the day to day goes up to 49.5, so 49.5 + 20 - 50 = -19.5k. Maybe minus a smidgen on the interest... Too lazy to figure it out. Nonetheless it's getting worse.
With deflation, the first year the person is going -15 k in the hole that first year, and the next year (41.5 + 20 - 50) = -11.5k in the hole the next year. In a few years the person has a net positive cashflow and that debt (or savings loss) that they accumulated in the first two years will be smoothed over pretty fast.
With inflation, why the hell did someone sell that 200k house to the person, unless there was a crazy idea that the nominal value of the house would monotonically go up at a rate that beats inflation.
With deflation, it was probably still a stupid sale, but well at least there's a chance s/he'll pull out of it, if they don't sell the house from under, as indeed the nominal value has gone down. I feel like home tenancy (versus default, eviction, and turnover) creates for a stabler society, and I'm all for that.
Now, if I made a mistake in my math somewhere, let me know.
>And in a debt based society-which isn't going to change-continual inflation is the best option.
You haven't convinced me of that. I think continual inflation is the best option if you're a banker. Or a politician. The math I've written up above bears out the notion that deflation is good, even for those who are in debt, unless you are really rearing to sell your assets and jump like a hyper meerkat on arbitrage opportunities. There are reasons why deflation is considered 'bad', namely that it appears to coincide with the loss of jobs, and I think that's mostly because the broad-stroke reason why jobs are lost is because of technology and because technology causes deflation, and indeed, deflation is the mechanism by which technology causes the loss of jobs.
- dnautics 16y agoHere, I made a spreadsheet of the whole thing. https://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=0AnuVSPZl-I22dHBiRmxQSmVfdjNfUjR6WjBSXzR6TUE&hl=en&authkey=CJnWwvYK https://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=0AnuVSPZl-I22dHBiRmx... In the deflation scenario, even though the house has lost nominal value from $200k to $27k, our family spent only a total of 8 years in debt and, amazingly, at the outset of 20 years accumulated 2 millions dollars in real (year 0) value. In the inflation scenario, although the house has gained nominal value from $200k to $1M, our family spent all those years in debt. Towards the last 8 years, the appreciating nominal value of the home was no longer able to suffice as an investment to counter the loss of spending power, and the family wound up in the hole... 100k in (year 0) value. There was only one year that cashing out on the house would have made nominal sense (year 1) and even so, that represented a net real value loss. Hell, I was a nice banker and didn't charge interest on the bank debt. (update: I threw in wage inflation, too, lagged it behind half a year). Now things are looking a bit better for our scrappy family and they come out at the end with a real net worth that's only down about 9k in year zero dollars. But at least they're not in the hole! Of course, that 9k can also be thought as 54k, or probably better, a quarter of the the year's wage.
- sethg 16y agoYou’re assuming that in a deflationary environment, your hypothetical family’s nominal income will stay constant over a 20-year period. Nice work, if you can get it. If I work in a widget factory and the price of widgets goes down because of deflation, while my nominal wages remain constant, then my wages as a share of that price goes up. That situation can’t continue for very long. The factory’s shareholders want a real return on their investment, especially since they could just cash in their stock, put the cash under a mattress, and wait for the price of everything to go down further. If the factory itself is in debt, the creditors will be demanding the same nominal payment as before, further squeezing the shareholders. So either I have to accept a cut in my nominal wages, or I have to make more widgets per hour for the same nominal wage, or I get laid off. And when I and lots of people like me have less money to spend, the people who manufacture all the things that we buy have to reduce their prices further, thus increasing the squeeze on their employees’ wages, etc., etc.
- 16y ago