4 ms·
What we should have instead is a cryptographically secure voting system where no one can prove how they voted but can verify that their vote was counted properl
by EGreg 8y ago
What we should have instead is a cryptographically secure voting system where no one can prove how they voted but can verify that their vote was counted properly.
The trick is just to have people scan a QR code when they register, to make sure it’s one vote one person.
- cbsmith 8y agoPart of knowing your vote was counted properly means knowing what votes were recorded for you.
- maccam94 8y agoVotes have to be deniable to prevent coerced or paid votes.
- ch4s3 8y agoDeniable voting is as others have mentioned, the whole point. Also paper ballots are dead simple (though expensive) to audit.
- thatfrenchguy 8y agoIt’s called paper ballots and you going to the vote booth
- tzs 8y agoI wonder if you are being downvoted because you said "cryptographically" and people think you are suggesting something with a blockchain? Anyway, such a system as you want has been designed, and is inexpensive and works well with existing systems, and makes it easy for third parties to audit the results: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scantegrity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scantegrity
- lwansbrough 8y agoHow can the system prove that my vote counted correctly if I can’t personally verify who my vote was counted for? This system obviously requires centralized trust (which I’m not against in practice) — but is there any provably secure way to make such a system decentralized? (Yes, blockchain..)
- 0xb100db1ade 8y agoZero knowledge proofs come to mind. You could prove you voted for one of a set of people without saying which one
- EGreg 8y agoYou should learn about off-the-record messaging, zero-knowledge proofs and blinded signatures. It's not obvious that centralized trust is required and in fact it isn't.
- tzs 8y ago> How can the system prove that my vote counted correctly if I can’t personally verify who my vote was counted for? In the Scantegrity sysem you can personally verify who your vote was counted for.
- EGreg 8y agoI am not sure how a blockchain would be helpful to this endeavor at all. My guess is that certain types of messages are just knee jerk downvoted. However, a Merkle tree may actually be extremely helpful when tallying the results of various districts. Why not have each person simply receive a random off-the-record perfect forward secrecy token and vote once and have all the votes stored in a Merkle tree?