5 ms·
To me this headline is phrased in a way that gives the impression that whales are visiting places because they are prospective mining sites (maybe curious). H
by mc32 8y ago
To me this headline is phrased in a way that gives the impression that whales are visiting places because they are prospective mining sites (maybe curious).
However, the text makes clear that that outfits are exploring places which coincidentally seem to be used by whales --if confirmed mining plans may need to be altered.
[in other words it implies some causation, but there appears to be none]
- mojomark 8y agoTotally read the headline the same way. I thought sea life were fighting 'the man' for a moment. Alternative [more responsible?] headline: Newly Conjectured Whale Habitat May Thwart Deep Sea Mining Prospects
- ianai 8y agoWhere’s the “thwart”? It’s open ocean between Hawaii and Mexico. I don’t know of any political force to stop development regardless.
- Johnny555 8y agoFrom the article: They acknowledge that more research will need to be done to prove that the marks were made by whales—but if their suspicions turn out to be correct, it could impact licensing for mining in such areas.
- PakG1 8y agoNewly Conjectured Whale Habitat May Thwart Deep Sea Mining Prospects I'd still read that as whales fighting 'the man', as in, they need to defend their natural home turf from destructive resource harvesting, ala Ferngully or Avatar.
- userbinator 8y agoThe sentence is a bit unusually phrased; I parsed it several times as prospective mining sites being visited by depressed whales and became rather puzzled.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoAnd in my quick first read I thought they were accusing the whales of making 4000 meter deep tracks (which would be a serious mining operation for a whale!) as opposed to finding tracks at a depth of 4000m, which makes way more sense.
- code_duck 8y agoRight, it should be phrased the other way around - researchers find that prospective mining sites are being placed in deep locations that whales visit to forage for food.
- pasta 8y agoEh, no. They did not discover that mining sites are being placed in deep locations. They discovered that whales visit those locations because they dive deeper than thought. So maybe: "Deep diving whales may cause licensing issues for prospective mining sites".
- code_duck 8y agoThe phrase is ‘deep locations that whales visit’. My intent was to phrase it in a more precise but not necessarily more poetic way. I think the issue is that the mining sites are going to cause issues for whales, which in turn causes issues for mining licensing, due to the environmental portion of regulations. The whales were there first, and your version again inverts the main topic of the article, which is actually beside the point.
- quietbritishjim 8y agoThe use of the word "that" and the lack of a comma means that "that whales visit ..." is a restrictive clause. Contrast with "placed in deep locations, which whales visit ...".
- pvaldes 8y agoAt this moment is just a theory. If you find unexpected damage at the deep sea bottom structure, most of the time the culprit is the man via deep-trawls