3 ms·
Despite your many reasons to discount the first experiment, their conclusion over six separate experiments is more or less the same as yours: "it's plausible th
by dahart 8y ago
Despite your many reasons to discount the first experiment, their conclusion over six separate experiments is more or less the same as yours: "it's plausible that rituals can have useful effects on behavior" vs "Our body of evidence suggests that rituals can have beneficial consequences for self-control."
What evidence is there that people in this study might have been lying?
I think it's interesting that you completely dismiss calorie counting, which is the only long term strategy that I've seen work consistently for myself & others for weight loss. Why do you say it's wildly inaccurate? How inaccurate is wildly? How accurate does it need to be in order to work?
- prestonh 8y agoCalorie counting can be wildly inaccurate while still producing the desired effect of weight loss. It probably has more to do with mindful consumption of food than getting the numbers exactly right.
- jamii 8y ago> What evidence is there that people in this study might have been lying? People tend to systematically misreport food intake (eg https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/133/3/895S/4688054 https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/133/3/895S/4688054). People are really bad at estimating portion sizes (eg https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article-abstract/35/4/727/4812565 https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article-abstract/35/4/727/4812...). If you run a non-blinded experiment using a self-reported measure that is well known to be wildly misreported and only get a small effect size to boot, it's on you to prove that you actually affected behavior and not just reporting.
- dahart 8y agoI totally buy both of those claims (and thanks for the sources!), but I don’t see how that necessarily affects this study. The human bias is (unsurprisingly) toward under-reporting consumption in both studies you cite. People aren’t randomly inaccurate, they are consistently underestimating. The self control study showed a decrease in reported consumption, so it doesn’t matter if people under-report food intake or portion sizes, what matters is the numbers went down anyway, right? The bias is present before, during, and after the self control study.